Employees in the top three levels of 21 state agencies could be
fired at will under a new rule supported by Gov. Mark Sanford.
The rule is included as a temporary provision of the $5 billion
state budget bill approved by the Legislature and awaiting Sanford's
signature.
The governor is expected to issue budget vetoes next week,
spokesman Will Folks said, but he will keep this provision.
The change would affect departments run by the eight
constitutional officers and the 13 agencies in the governor's
Cabinet.
Sanford could face questions about the change today, when he
speaks to the annual meeting of the S.C. State Employees Association
-- which doesn't like the new provision at all.
Sanford believes "government ought to run more like a business,"
Folks said. "You don't hire someone to do a job and not give them
the flexibility they need in hiring."
Most state jobs fall into two categories:
- Political appointees serve "at will," meaning they can be fired
at any time.
- Civil servants are protected by the state's grievance policy
and can be removed only under certain conditions.
Sanford believes the policy limits his ability to build an
administration. Agency heads he hires are often unable to bring in
their own teams because top employees are often protected civil
servants.
There are 19,789 employees who work for the 21 affected state
agencies. The State Budget and Control Board, which handles
personnel matters for state agencies, is still calculating how many
employees could be affected by the new rules.
"This gives constitutional officers and Cabinet directors
much-needed flexibility," Folks said.
But it's too far-reaching, said Broadus Jamerson, executive
director of the S.C. State Employees Association. The association
had no problem making agency directors and deputy directors
political appointees, he said, but "we are opposed to the third
level."
Under the rule, employees who report to the agency director "or
report directly to a person who reports directly" to an agency head
are "at will."
"When you get down to that level, you start deterring career
employees from working themselves into good positions," Jamerson
said.
The association believes state employees will not want to advance
into the upper echelons of an agency for fear of losing their jobs.
Some employees fear promotion could become a tool for eliminating
their jobs. If a director doesn't like an employee, he can simply be
promoted to the third-highest level and fired.
The provision is not meant to threaten employees, Folks said.
"The intent is to give agency directors long-overdue authority to
make decisions regarding people who are going to be an integral part
of their success," Folks said. "That's the bottom line. There is no
ulterior motive."
The rule expires after one year, unless it is included in the
budget again next year. Sanford supported making the change in
permanent law, but a deal with lawmakers fell through in the final
week of the session.
Attorney General Henry McMaster supports the change. New state
leaders should be able to build their own teams, his spokesman
said.
When McMaster took over for former Attorney General Charlie
Condon, McMaster was surprised to learn that "virtually every
employee in the attorney general's office was protected," said his
spokesman, Trey Walker.
McMaster was lucky, Walker said, that he inherited a team he
mostly respected. "But he was not able to bring in people wholesale,
because a lot of folks were protected," Walker said.
McMaster has 127 employees, and Walker estimated that 25 could be
affected.