Scholar scours
Westmoreland’s papers in search of history
By JOHN
MONK News
Columnist
General William Westmoreland was buried Saturday at West Point,
but the search for the meaning of his life goes on — right in the
heart of Columbia.
“We can’t understand what happened in Vietnam and why unless we
understand William Westmoreland,” said Lewis “Bob” Sorley, a
military historian who, so far, has spent two years researching a
biography on Westmoreland.
Westmoreland, the South Carolina-born U.S. commander in Vietnam
from 1964 to 1968, died last week at 91.
On hearing of Westmoreland’s death, Sorley was hunkered down on
the second floor of the University of South Carolina’s Caroliniana
Library, wading through a scholar’s treasure — boxes filled with
thousands of Westmoreland’s papers.
When Sorley finds interesting information, he enters it into his
Apple G4 laptop. “I’m sort of the obsessive type. I don’t just
sample. I like to look at every one,” Sorley, author of four
previous books on Vietnam-related military history, said of
Westmoreland’s papers.
Sorley, 70, from Maryland, is the first scholar to systematically
go through Westmoreland’s papers, library officials said.
The review could take him months. The Caroliniana Library has one
of the nation’s most extensive collections of Westmoreland personal
papers — more than 70 boxes — 100,000-plus pages of letters, memos,
clippings, speeches, photos and assorted documents. They were
donated by the Westmorelands in the late 1990s.
Sorley is well-known in military history circles.
“He’s tireless in his research,” said retired Gen. John Sloan
Brown, the U.S. Army’s chief of military history at Fort McNair in
Washington, D.C.
Brown said Sorley’s Vietnam books — particularly a 1992 biography
of Gen. Creighton Abrams, who succeeded Westmoreland as commander in
Vietnam — are valuable contributions to history.
For a 1999 book on the war’s later years, “A Better War,” Sorley
found secret military files and got them declassified, Brown
said.
In that book, Sorley concluded Westmoreland’s strategy from 1964
to 1968 — requesting more and more U.S. troops to kill more and more
of the enemy — was a failure. By the time Westmoreland left Vietnam
in 1968, U.S. forces there had grown to 500,000 from 15,000 in 1964,
and 40,000 American soldiers had been killed. And the enemy had only
grown stronger.
Brown said it will be interesting to see whether Sorley modifies
earlier positions on Westmoreland in his new biography.
“Bob is open-minded,” Brown said. “He’s down there trying to come
to grips with Westmoreland’s legacy.”
Whatever Sorley comes up with is sure to be widely read, as well
as controversial, said Brown.
“He does have folks who disagree with him,” said Brown, adding
one Sorley contention is the United States could have won the
Vietnam War if politicians and generals had done things differently.
That’s a different take from many historians who argue the Vietnam
War was not winnable.
It is healthy for historians to advance well-researched points of
view, even though they provoke controversy, Brown said. “That’s how
the educational purposes of history are served.” And, he added, such
matters are relevant today, “now that we are in yet another
frustrating insurgency” in Iraq.
‘THE FINAL CHAPTER’
Sorley has the right background to decode Westmoreland’s career
for readers.
Like Westmoreland, Sorley is a West Point graduate. Westmoreland
graduated in 1936; Sorley, in 1956. After a 20-year career in the
Army that included stints in Vietnam, as an English teacher at West
Point, as a tank commander in Germany and as an officer in the
Pentagon, Sorley spent seven years with the Central Intelligence
Agency. He then retired to research and write books.
After more than 20 years researching Vietnam-related topics,
Sorley is familiar with the major libraries around the country where
Vietnam- and Westmoreland-related documents are found. They include
the Vietnam archives at Texas Tech in Lubbock, Texas; the U.S. Army
archives at Carlisle Barracks, Pa.; and the Lyndon Johnson
Presidential Library in Austin, Texas.
One of the most valuable sources — a kind of day-by-day diary
kept by Westmoreland during his Vietnam years — is at Fort McNair,
Sorley said. Regularly, Westmoreland dictated observations to a
stenographer, Sorley said.
More than half of Sorley’s Westmoreland biography will cover the
general’s Vietnam years, from 1964 to 1968, and his years as
Armychief of staff, from 1968 to 1972, when Westmoreland still dealt
with Vietnam. Publication is at least three years off, Sorley
estimated.
On Thursday, Sorley interrupted his research at the Caroliniana
Library to go to Charleston for Westmoreland’s funeral. Then, he
traveled to West Point to attend the burial Saturday.
“It’s kind of the final chapter,” said Sorley.
‘AS LONG AS IT TAKES’
Sorley said he’s keeping an open mind about Westmoreland.
Already, he said, he’s found plenty of material in the Caroliniana
Library archives to rebut the stereotype that Westmoreland always
was stiff and impersonal.
That material includes hundreds of personal letters — including
“bread and butter” and congratulatory notes — that Westmoreland sent
to family, friends and fellow soldiers over the years, Sorley
said.
“He was very aggressive about cultivating relationships,” Sorley
said. “You could say it was self-serving. Or you could say he was
doing it on behalf of the Army, or you could say he was just
naturally friendly.”
Sorley has spent about five weeks in Columbia since last spring.
He’s managed to go through 13 out of the 70-plus boxes at the
Caroliniana. Much of the material is letters that Sorley hadn’t seen
before.
“I’m going to be back two weeks next month, and two weeks the
month after that,” said Sorley, who commutes from his home in
Maryland. “I don’t know how long it will take. I’m here as long as
it
takes.” |