Justices uphold
death sentence for killing social workers
JEFFREY
COLLINS Associated
Press
COLUMBIA, S.C. - The state Supreme Court has
upheld the death sentence of a man convicted of killing three Aiken
County social workers in 1996.
The justices ruled Monday that David Mark Hill was properly found
competent to stand trial and the jury was selected
appropriately.
Hill, 44, walked into the Department of Social Services office in
North Augusta in September 1996 and killed three workers.
The court did overturn Hill's conviction on attempted murder and
burglary charges, but that won't affect his death sentence. The
justices said prosecutors could not try Hill on a burglary charge
because there was no locked door or other barrier between the lobby
and the social workers' offices.
Hill said he killed social worker James Riddle because Riddle was
involved in a case that removed Hill's children from his home. Hill
said he killed Michael Gregory because Gregory had seen him with the
gun and Josie Curry "because she was black," according to court
documents.
A day later, police found Hill near some railroad tracks. He had
shot himself in the mouth in a suicide attempt. He confessed to
investigators after he was taken to the hospital.
The justices said the confession should be allowed because Hill's
injuries did not make him mentally incompetent and he was not
directly told he would die.
Hill suffered some memory loss from the gunshot wound, but the
justices ruled that did not affect his defense.
The justices split on a jury selection matter. The 3-2 majority
ruled that the trial judge did not have to agree to the defense's
request to ask each potential juror if they could be the lone
holdout for a life or death sentence.
In a dissent, justices John Waller and James Moore said lawyers
should be able to ask if a juror can vote independent of the
majority. |