COLUMBIA--The controversy surrounding the
massive "kitchen sink" bill just won't die.
Members of the S.C. House of Representatives say they were blindsided
by Gov. Mark Sanford's actions last week after the General Assembly's
override of his veto of the Life Sciences Act. They worry Sanford is
working against the General Assembly instead of working with it.
The governor held a news conference March 18 and announced he would
continue efforts to kill the bill.
The act, originally created to provide research opportunities and
economic development in biotechnology and related fields, grew to include
more than 20 pieces of loosely connected legislation.
Sanford opposed the measure over what he termed "politically driven,
pork-barrel spending" and said he was considering challenging the bill in
court over constitutional violations.
Sanford's news conference came just hours after House members passed
his income tax reduction plan and, according to several House GOP leaders,
just a day after the governor's co-chief of staff Tom Davis gave members
the impression the governor was OK with the General Assembly overriding
his veto.
"I don't know the exact words he used, but that was the clear message
to members," said House Ways and Means Chairman Bobby Harrell,
R-Charleston. "And the next day they had a press conference saying we did
a terrible thing."
Davis said the controversy stems from a misunderstanding. The
Legislature moved quickly to override the governor's veto, leaving Davis
with only a few minutes on the House floor to speak to members. He was
able to speak to only about four before they voted.
"I told them the governor had made his feelings clear on the matter and
the best thing they could do was vote their conscience," he said.
House members took this to mean the governor would hold no grudge about
an override.
"We got the feeling that the governor didn't care and maybe even
invited the override," said John Graham Altman III, R-Charleston.
Davis, who had several angry House members approach him this week, said
the governor issued a five-page explanation of why he vetoed the bill and
it was "ludicrous" to think the governor wouldn't care about the override.
"I told them that if that was their impression from what I said, then
that was my mistake," he said.
Speaker of the House David Wilkins, R-Greenville, said he has heard
from several members regarding the incident. He said the misunderstanding
stems not only from Davis' words but also from the fact that Sanford's
office did not lobby for support for sustaining his veto.
"When a governor wants a certain vote, his people usually come around
and say, 'Can you help us on this?' or 'We need your vote.' They don't
usually say, 'Vote your conscience.' "
Wilkins and several other House members said they had no problem with
Davis. What they are bothered by is a move that seems to confirm their
worst fears.
"This is about the governor and the House," Wilkins said. "Within four
hours of our passing his income tax plan, he holds a press conference and
says we trampled on the taxpayers."
Wilkins said the controversy didn't signal the end of the House and
governor's office working together but did leave a lot of members feeling
distrustful of the governor.
When the session started this year, House and Senate GOP leaders
promised that the Republican-led legislative and executive branches would
work together. But from the beginning, party solidarity seemed somewhat
fragile.
In December, Sanford floated a poll that seemed to pit the governor
against the General Assembly, angering many legislators.
Throughout his first two years in office, Sanford has struggled to get
any meaningful legislation passed. With his income tax proposal close to
the finish line, he took legislators to task over a disagreement.
To many in the public, this proves the popular governor is a maverick
who sticks to his guns no matter what. To others, it confirms the
suspicion that he can't work well with others.
"He has no idea what it takes to run state government," said Sen. Phil
Leventis, D-Sumter. "And to tell you the truth, he has no respect for
those who do. He would rather operate in theory than to accomplish
anything in the practical world, and his record of success proves that."
But Senate President Pro Tem Glenn McConnell, R-Charleston, sees it
another way. He said the governor has spent two years trying to get his
agenda through with little success. This year, legislators have tanked all
but one of his proposals, the income tax plan.
"I don't see where he was gaining ground using his old strategy,"
McConnell said. "Maybe he's tried the nice way and now he's decided to try
another way. I felt all along that if his agenda didn't move, he would
start taking on the General Assembly. And really, who can blame him?"