COLUMBIA - Declaring that illegal immigrants cost the state too much
money, a South Carolina lawmaker on Thursday proposed denying them access
to some hospital care and shutting them out of public schools.
State Rep. Mike Pitts said his proposal, quickly criticized by
immigrant advocates and the state's hospitals, should be passed even if it
violates federal laws. Washington, Pitts said, isn't doing "anything to
attempt to solve this problem."
"We have a big problem in this country," he said. "Illegals are taxing
the local tax base and eating up the resources."
The proposal is the latest state effort at tackling illegal immigration
as reform efforts idle in Congress. Last year, lawmakers introduced
roughly 650 bills targeting immigrants, with 32 states enacting 84
immigration laws involving everything from college tuition to driver's
licenses, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.
About 1,200 immigration bills have been introduced across the nation
this year, said Dirk Hegen, a policy associate with the group. A Texas
proposal would bar the babies of illegal immigrants from receiving state
benefits such as food stamps, health care or public housing.
The sweeping South Carolina bill would prevent illegal immigrants from
receiving care for nonlife-threatening conditions, enrolling in public
schools and receiving any taxpayer-funded benefit, including retirement
and disability.
South Carolina already prevents illegal immigrants from receiving most
public benefits, such as welfare and food stamps.
A 1982 U.S. Supreme Court ruling says public schools can't turn illegal
immigrants away, and federal law requires hospitals treat anyone who comes
into an emergency room, regardless of whether they can pay.
Allan Stalvey, vice president of the South Carolina Hospital
Association, said physicians don't want to become immigration officers by
default, nor can they immediately determine whether an illness is
life-threatening.
Pitts hopes the bill will pass, but acknowledges legislators will make
changes.
"I realize and fully understand that immigration is supposed to be the
purview of the federal government," Pitts said. "But I don't see the
federal government doing anything to attempt to solve this problem for the
future."