State Sen. Glenn McConnell needs
to keep an open mind as he seeks public input on property tax
reform.
But instead, the powerful president pro tempore of the Senate has
staked out his position, which appears to be a declaration of war
against local governments. And while urging people to participate in
public hearings set up this summer on state tax reform, McConnell
seems to be telling people what to say. He wants people to come
drown out the voices of the municipal and county governments, which
depend on the property tax to pay for local public
services.
In a special column printed on
this page today, McConnell says, "One of the cruelest taxes of all,
the property tax, is long overdue for reform or even extinguishment
in South Carolina."
He says he hopes that the voices of the people from the mountains
to the coast can drown out the paid lobbyists for local governments.
But the voices of the local governments need to be heard. These
are the governments closest to the people. Would a Hilton Head
Island resident call McConnell in Charleston to get mosquitoes
sprayed or a stray dog picked up or a new building inspected in our
community? No. McConnell has different duties, and we ask that he
respect the duties that the local governments are asked to carry
out.
It's easy to call supporters of local government "termites" and
claim towns, counties and schools "spend our money like they have a
blank check." But it is not easy for local governments to provide
all the services the public demands, whether it is schools, parks,
planning, solid waste disposal or public safety. And any changes to
the current tax scheme would have rippling effects with broad
ramifications. All those nuances, and their effect on local
communities, need to be understood completely and debated with open
minds.
Property taxes are the whipping boy because property values have
increased dramatically, here and around the nation. If citizens are
upset about local governments "writing blank checks," they already
have someone to turn to -- the local people they elect to serve
them. They can complain to the local mayor or county council member
about the tax rate, but the open marketplace sets the value of
property.
McConnell lists a number of different proposals or options on the
table to reform state taxation. Encouraging the public to pay
attention and give input on those ideas is commendable. So is the
effort by the legislature to study taxation in a broader,
deliberative way before the next legislative session in January.
But anyone can cry out for property tax relief. It is harder to
figure out an equitable way to deal with that lost revenue. Everyone
needs to keep an open mind.