MOX next logical
step in dismantling Russian warheads
By VAL
LOISELLE Guest
Columnist
Missing in the public debate over the planned use of mixed oxide
fuel in nuclear power plants is the success of the program to
convert dangerous highly enriched uranium from Russia’s nuclear
arsenal into fuel for U.S. power plants.
For the past decade, the United States and Russia have been
working together to beat their powerful 20th-century nuclear swords
into modern electricity plowshares — the electricity that powers our
everyday lives.
This little-reported partnership has achieved a remarkable
success. About 10 percent of all the electricity Americans use at
home and at work comes from nuclear materials that had formerly been
the explosive core of the Soviet Union’s nuclear weapons arsenal.
More than 8,000 nuclear warheads have been dismantled by the Russian
government, and the highly enriched uranium has been transformed
into low-enriched material that serves as a fuel in nuclear power
plants.
This low-enriched uranium is generating electricity at about 50
nuclear plants across the United States, where reactors are tapping
the energy and disabling nuclear materials from Soviet missiles that
were once targeted at U.S. cities. In turn, the Russians are getting
hard currency — about $3 billion, under a long-term contract the
United States and Russia signed in 1993.
This program of turning Soviet weapons into electricity has been
a historic demilitarization success. But there are still mountains
of nuclear materials rattling around in insecure countries,
particularly Russia — not only uranium, but also tons of
plutonium.
Russia reportedly has about 50 tons of weapons-ready plutonium
from the old Soviet weapons program. The threat is obvious: Through
the black market, some of the plutonium could fall into the hands of
terrorists or outlaw governments.
Just as highly enriched uranium from scrapped warheads is being
diluted to make reactor fuel for nuclear plants, essentially the
same can be done with plutonium. A demonstration project is about to
begin. The United States has arranged for the first shipment of
plutonium from Russia, due to arrive any day at the Charleston Naval
Weapons Station. The plutonium will be blended with uranium to
produce what’s known as mixed oxide fuel, or MOX, for use at nuclear
power plants. An expert panel of the National Academy of Sciences
has said the production and use of MOX fuel is safe.
No surprise, anti-nuclear activists oppose the use of MOX fuel,
claiming that a ship carrying the plutonium might be vulnerable to
terrorist attack. But U.S. officials have made it clear that
safeguards are in place to meet such threats. On the other hand, if
we allow the plutonium to remain in Russia at poorly guarded weapons
facilities, the threat is much greater. We would leave it there at
our own peril.
It’s difficult to overstate the merits of this agreement. Without
a program to eliminate weapons-grade uranium and now plutonium, the
nuclear warheads would still exist, capable of being used in a
nuclear weapon against the United States or any other country.
Instead of risking that these materials might fall into the hands of
the world’s most dangerous people, nuclear weapons materials are
being disabled — and all destructive capability totally eliminated —
in the process of providing our country with electric power.
The fact is, nearly every nuclear power plant in the United
States has been fueled at some point over the past 10 years with
uranium from dismantled Soviet warheads. With energy security such
an important consideration, it’s worth noting that the energy we
have received from that uranium fuel is equivalent to the energy in
4,000 supertankers of oil.
By showing that nuclear swords can be converted into electricity
plowshares, we are pursuing the goal of generating electricity for
U.S. homes and businesses while preventing nuclear weapons materials
from falling into the hands of terrorists. This is a challenge and
an opportunity that we cannot dismiss.
Mr. Loiselle, an adjunct professor of nuclear topics at USC, is a
nuclear energy and environmental consultant in the Columbia
area. |