A better way on
Medicaid
By THOMAS RAVENEL Guest columnist
Despite South Carolina’s reputation for being a well-managed
state, the facts are that mandated spending threatens, over time, to
eat away at our financial security.
The U.S. Congressional Budget Office estimates that, under
current law, federal spending as a percentage of gross domestic
product will rise from about 20 percent — where it has mostly been
since the end of World War II — to 34 percent by 2050.
And that’s just Washington. The states face similar problems,
driven by the increasing expense of mandated programs such as
Medicaid, which is already ravaging state budgets from California to
New York.
Without serious Medicaid reform, South Carolina faces a major tax
increase or cuts in services — or some combination of both — that no
one will like and that will hurt the state’s competitiveness.
Fortunately, a serious proposal for reform exists that could prove
to be a model for the way other states will eventually tackle the
problem.
Gov. Mark Sanford has proposed the establishment of personal
health accounts for each non-disabled Medicaid recipient in the
state. These accounts, which would be owned, would give each
Medicaid recipient a vested interest in the quality and
affordability of his or her own health care, because with ownership
comes the power to choose.
The key concept here is ownership.
The Sanford plan gives Medicaid recipients a stake in the
program. Rather than simply being forced to take what the state has
to offer, they will be empowered to seek out more choices, better
care, lower costs — all things that are anathema to the
state-sponsored dependency culture.
The available plans could range from full-scale managed care to
preferred provider organizations to a combination of catastrophic
hospital insurance and cash available directly for less urgent
needs. At a minimum, the Sanford plan is careful to specify, all
approved plans would have to cover the mandatory services provided
by Medicaid.
The requirement that the state approve the plans is an essential
safeguard that protects some of our most vulnerable citizens from
being preyed upon by fly-by-night operations.
The Sanford reform proposal has already drawn predictable
opposition from out-of-state liberal special interests who make a
good living advocating for the dependency culture. Their arguments —
that services will be cut and that children and families will suffer
— are the same ones they tried against welfare reform, another
policy initiative that began in the states and has succeeded beyond
everyone’s expectations.
The proposed reforms — and the Sanford administration is already
seeking a federal waiver to put them into place — would mean price
competition leading to greater savings for consumers and, in the
long run, the state.
It may not seem like a pressing problem now, but left unchecked,
South Carolina’s future Medicaid obligations threaten to cause
serious damage to the state’s budget and economy. The Sanford reform
points the state in the right direction, not just because they will
produce budget savings, but because it will lead to healthier
people. There is no reason not to do it, despite the naysaying and
predictions of doom that those from outside our state might
make.
Mr. Ravenel is a Charleston businessman and former candidate for
U.S.
Senate. |