Ties to developer
puts Edge on edgeLegislator
scrutinized for his work with Burroughs and
ChapinBy SAMMY
FRETWELLsfretwell@thestate.com
For each of the past two winters, state Rep. Tracy Edge has voted
to keep cities from bringing down billboards across South
Carolina.
The company that Edge works for has a billboard business with
almost 1,000 signs.
This March, Edge led the fight for a bill to make it hard for
local governments to control development through zoning.
The company Edge works for — Burroughs and Chapin — is one of the
state’s most visible developers.
Edge’s votes in the Legislature have prompted a stream of
criticism during the past year, putting the spotlight on his role as
legislator-developer.
Legislators and lobbyists says Edge’s actions would help the
company he works for. Letters published in the pages of S.C.
newspapers take him to task for his votes.
In late March 2005, some Horry County residents filed an ethics
complaint against Edge for supporting the billboard legislation. The
House Ethics Committee dismissed the complaint, saying it was
unfounded.
But Edge’s critics persist.
“You’d have to have blinders on not to recognize that some of his
power and authority benefits the company he works for,” said Bob
Logan, whose group, We the People, filed the complaint.
Edge, vice president of real estate at Burroughs and Chapin in
Myrtle Beach, said the criticism is an attempt by political enemies,
such as Logan, to discredit him.
Edge said he is no different than most citizen-legislators. South
Carolina is a small state with a part-time legislature, meaning most
representatives and senators have full-time jobs away from the State
House.
The key is knowing when to abstain from voting and how support of
or opposition to legislation can appear even when it’s legal,
political scientists say.
Edge, R-Horry, said he followed the state’s ethics law when
voting on bills. Public officials cannot take action that would help
only the company they work for. The law does not prohibit
legislators such as Edge from voting for bills that affect an
industry or class of companies, including the ones they work
for.
Edge said he would quit Burroughs and Chapin if the company
ordered him to support a bill.
“If I would have been up here doing the company’s business, this
would have been outed a long time ago,” he said. “I wouldn’t have
been re-elected.”
At the State House, Edge is considered a tenacious legislator
with increasing influence.
He is a member and subcommittee chairman of the House Ways and
Means Committee, the panel that writes the state budget. And he is a
senior member of the Horry County legislative delegation.
INTERN TO EXECUTIVE
Edge, 39, said Burroughs and Chapin is a high-profile development
company — and an easy target for critics.
His employment by Burroughs and Chapin has been brought up in
past political races. Once, an opponent’s advertisement depicted him
as a puppet of the company. In 2000, Democratic opponent Harold
Bessent said Edge had helped the company with tax legislation
friendly to its interests, a charge that Edge denied.
This year, Edge has no Republican primary opponent, but does face
Democrat Charles J. Randall in the general election.
Edge has run successfully for his northern Grand Strand House
seat five times since 1996. Edge said he’s won each time because
voters know he is from a good family and is a person of
integrity.
“It’s an issue in every race I’ve got,” Edge said of his
Burroughs and Chapin connection. “But those things, people say,
don’t stick.”
Edge, the son of North Myrtle Beach’s first mayor, has worked for
Burroughs and Chapin since 1993, rising from an unpaid intern to his
current position.
Edge has coordinated construction for Broadway at the Beach,
perhaps the company’s most successful development project on the
Grand Strand. More recently, he helped close a deal for a NASCAR
speed park in Gatlinburg, Tenn.
Today, Edge acquires mostly out-of-state land for the company.
Affable and easy to talk with, Edge said the company considers him a
good negotiator.
Burroughs and Chapin executive Doug Wendel, a former county
administrator and aide to former U.S. Rep. John Jenrette, said he
rarely talks with Edge during the legislative session and doesn’t
require him to support company positions on bills.
In fact, Wendel said Edge’s election to the Legislature has
impeded his career. The company cut Edge’s pay by 40 percent when he
was first elected, Edge said, because serving in the Legislature
keeps him from work three days a week.
“It’s hurt him by going there, as it relates to his career,’’
Wendel said. “He could have been much further ahead in the company
with a much better job and paid a whole lot more money.”
Nonetheless, Edge’s job brings attention to him and places
emphasis on how he handles legislation, said Blease Graham, a
political scientist at the University of South Carolina.
“It makes a legislator vulnerable to criticism and it may
generate opposition,” Graham said. “It’s a question the legislator
has to answer ultimately.”
Van Kornegay, one of the billboard industry’s most vocal
opponents, said Edge should have disclosed that he works for
Burroughs and Chapin when advocating looser billboard restrictions
this year.
Kornegay wrote a letter to The State newspaper in March in
response to a letter Edge wrote. Edge’s letter said the billboard
law would protect property rights.
“A public servant who had a special interest who writes an
opinion piece should reveal that he has a financial gain behind it,”
Kornegay said. “He said he was protecting property owners. But
property owners like me are upset because billboards are showing up
in our neighborhood.”
The bill requires local governments to pay more to billboard
companies to get rid of billboards that cities or counties deem
unsightly.
Coastal Outdoor Advertising, a division of Burroughs and Chapin,
has 850 signs.
Last year, Edge voted for the bill when it came up in the House.
In February, Edge was among the majority of legislators who voted to
override Gov. Mark Sanford’s veto of the bill.
CAMPAIGN MONEY, SUPPORT
When it comes to his voting on legislation that would benefit
Burroughs and Chapin, records show Edge:
• Co-sponsored a bill in 1999 that
limits fees developers can be charged to cover the cost of new
development on government services. County governments have said the
new law makes it difficult to impose such fees.
Edge said it only tells governments when the fees can be
used.
• Spoke against giving more
authority to the state coastal division on permitting decisions.
Burroughs and Chapin lobbied against a 2000 bill that increased
public input on state environmental permits. The bill failed.
Edge said he thought the bill would “politicize” decisions on
coastal environmental permits.
• Co-sponsored and served as a
floor leader this year in the fight for “takings” legislation, which
makes it harder for local governments to regulate development. It
requires compensation when zoning laws devalue property.
Critics say the proposal would cripple governments’ ability to
control dense commercial development and protect private homeowners.
It has not passed the Senate.
Edge said it protects property rights for the average person.
Burroughs and Chapin officials also say much of their property is
covered by development agreements with local governments, so the
change in law would not directly affect their land. However, Wendel
said it could affect land the company has acquired more recently.
Burroughs and Chapin owns about 30,000 acres in and around Myrtle
Beach.
Wallace Scarborough, a Charleston Republican, said there’s little
doubt Edge helped Burroughs and Chapin with the takings legislation
this year.
Scarborough opposed the takings lesislation.
“What he was doing was in the best interests of the company he
represents,” Scarborough said. “Absolutely, it will help
developers.”
Records show Burroughs and Chapin backs Edge in re-election
campaigns.
Since 1996, Edge has received more than $20,000 in campaign
contributions from Burroughs and Chapin, its employees and company
consultants, according to campaign finance reports.
The maximum contribution per election cycle is $1,000. Edge has
raised more than $400,000 since his first campaign.
Among that is $5,000 directly from Burroughs and Chapin and
another $1,000 from Columbia Venture, a Burroughs backed firm.
Columbia Venture has had plans to develop a flood plain along the
Congaree River in Columbia.
Wendel has given more than $1,200. He said he’s glad to help
Edge, whom he said is like a son.
Reach Fretwell at (803) 771-8537.
|