COLUMBIA--Opponents of Gov. Mark Sanford's
income tax reduction plan, his top legislative priority, were successful
Wednesday in fighting off the proposal long enough essentially to kill it.
After three failed attempts in seven hours to seat Democrats
filibustering the measure, supporters of the governor's plan gave up and
adjourned debate. With four days left in the legislative session and the
governor's budget vetoes next up on the Senate calendar, the proposal has
little chance of revival.
"We just couldn't get the votes," said Senate President Pro Tem Glenn
McConnell, R-Charleston. "Unless we can find three more votes somewhere,
the fight is over. And that's a shame because it's an economic development
plan that South Carolina needs."
The news reached the governor at the end of a long day. Earlier, the
S.C. House of Representative overrode 105 of his 106 budget vetoes.
"We've made it three-fourths of the way through the process," Sanford
said. "Unfortunately, that last part is the toughest. We have the votes to
do it, but the Senate rules have prevented us from getting to a vote. We
aren't giving up yet."
Sanford's tax plan would lower the state's highest income tax bracket
by .225 percentage points a year for 10 years, lowering the rate from 7
percent to 4.75 percent.
For two days, Senate Democrats, led by John Land of Manning, fought to
keep the proposal from the floor. Land and his supporters survived three
attempts to end the filibuster Wednesday. The closest Republicans came to
ending the filibuster was 25 votes, three short of the needed 28.
"They didn't want to win this," Land said. "They knew what a bad idea
this was. We just did the governor a big favor. We kept him from doing
serious damage."
For months, Sanford's proposal crept through the Senate. Fearing it
might not be addressed by the end of the session June 3, Republican
senators forced the issue, attaching it to a bill from the House.
The move let the governor's plan bypass the committee process and come
up first on the Senate calendar. Some senators expected a showdown
Tuesday, but too few supporters stayed in the chamber to break the
Democrats.
Supporters of the governor's plan avoided that problem Wednesday by
invoking a measure preventing any senator from leaving the chamber until
the debate ended.
Despite their best efforts to wait out Democrats, the Republicans ended
the struggle when it became clear they were not going to win.