EXCLUSIVE S.C. busts tax cheats Revenue agency’s new system expected to bring in millions
from noncompliers By JOHN
MONK News
Columnist
High-tech collector
South Carolina is cracking down on tax dodgers and deadbeats,
employing a sophisticated new computer system to increase tax
collections by at least $100 million over the next five years.
This week, the S.C. Department of Revenue will implement the
first phase of the high-tech system that — like the alien creature
in the movie “Predator” — will hunt down tax welchers and nail them
like they’ve never been nailed before.
The computer will send out 1,000 letters this week to suspected
noncompliers. In months to come, it will send out up to 3,000
letters a week.
“It will revolutionize tax collection in South Carolina,” said
Department of Revenue director Burnie Maybank. He said nonfilers and
tax underreporters deprive the state of tens of millions of dollars
each year.
Maybank’s new computer is actually two refrigerator-sized racks
with Hewlett-Packard servers and a storage device. The assemblage is
gleaming black with blinking red lights. Eventually, it will hold
more than 300 million records, more personal data about South
Carolinians than any computer system anywhere.
The computer gives state tax officials the ability to instantly
match and cross-index data about people and businesses from multiple
databases. It uses inconsistencies — such as someone with a $30,000
declared income buying an $80,000 car — to identify potential
offenders. Then, the computer writes suspected non-compliers a
letter, detailing its evidence and asking for an explanation — or
money.
The new computer can do the work of a small army of human
accountants, quickly spotting nonfilers and people who underreport
their income.
“That is the beauty of this system,” Maybank said. “It does our
audit selection for us.”
NOWHERE TO HIDE
Maybank said tens of thousands of South Carolinians either don’t
file income tax forms or underreport their income. In part, that is
because they know there is little chance they will be caught.
With its out-of-date computers, the state primarily catches only
the most obvious tax noncompliers, such as those who fail to report
big stock dividend checks, Maybank said.
In theory, the state is supposed to match up state and federal
tax data. But that didn’t happen easily. The IRS sent its data to
South Carolina on reels of tape that were difficult to access. Now,
the IRS data is loaded into the new computer and is instantly
retrievable.
The new system also will analyze data.
For example, it will pinpoint a filer who claims a $30,000
charitable contribution and only a $60,000 income, he said. It also
will scrutinize taxpayers in occupations that have a record of
noncompliance, such as real estate agents and airline pilots,
Maybank said.
The new computer was installed by Revenue Solutions, a
Massachusetts firm specializing in high-tech tax collection.
Its software goes by the generic name of “data warehouse.” Inside
the computer is a “virtual warehouse” of different sets of data —
including all S.C. residents’ state and federal tax forms, S.C.
Department of Motor Vehicle records and S.C. Employment Security
Commission records. The computer “mines” the data from different
databases.
Revenue Solutions installed a similar system for the state of
Massachusetts several years ago.
“We figure it brings us an extra $1 million to $1.5 million a
week,” Massachusetts revenue official Tim Connolly said. Over two
years, the system generated about $150 million for Massachusetts in
extra taxes, mostly from nonfilers and underreporters, he said.
S.C. tax officials estimate the computer will bring in $100
million over the next five years — the life of the Revenue Solutions
contract. Under that contract, the company gets no payment other
than a commission of 20 percent of the money collected.
(That money is not included in the $90 million that Maybank
promised legislators he would collect if they would allow Revenue to
hire more staffers.)
No one knows for sure how much money the new computer will bring
in. It will be another year or two before it and the related tax
collection processes run at peak efficiency. Meanwhile, officials
plan to load some 200 million additional business and other records
into the computer. Already, about 60 million records have been
loaded.
SUPER SAFEGUARDS
State tax officials say they are installing high-security
measures to protect the data. It is not connected to the Internet,
so hackers can’t get into it. Inside the Revenue Department, only
authorized people can access the data.
Officials also say they have fine-tuned the system to avoid
targeting the wrong people.
“We try very hard to verify everything; for example, that we have
the right John Smith,” said Terry Garber, Revenue’s senior
technology manager.
Since late February, the department has tested the system,
sending out 1,000 letters to suspected noncompliers
Already, Revenue has received $50,000 from noncompliers from that
test and located others who will pay back taxes in the future,
officials said.
One noncomplier was living in Florida. That state has no income
tax. But the individual owed S.C. income tax, officials said.
An additional $16,000 came from someone who had collected pension
earnings from a company in another state and wasn’t reporting those
earnings on his S.C. income tax, officials said.
Officials stress not every noncomplier is a tax cheat. Most make
math mistakes or genuinely do not understand how much taxes they
owe.
Maybank knows some people might resent his department’s new
computer. But most will like it, he said.
“The only thing that Joe Six-Pack hates more than paying taxes is
knowing that his neighbor has not paid his,” Maybank said.
Asked whether he’s got a nickname — like Jaws or Predator — for
the new computer, Maybank said, “If we had a nickname, it would be
something like ‘Fair Share and Not a Penny More.’” |