SOUTH
CAROLINA
2 studies criticize Medicaid
proposal
By Roddie Burris Knight Ridder
COLUMBIA - Two new analyses say South
Carolina's proposed Medicaid changes will reduce health coverage and
significantly raise costs to beneficiaries.
The analyses, by the Washington, D.C.-based Center on Budget and
Policy Priorities and Georgetown University's Public Policy
Institute, are among the first national looks at the S.C. Medicaid
proposal.
According to the studies, if the S.C. waiver is granted, the
state is unlikely to provide adequate money to cover long-term
chronic illnesses or for people with disabilities.
The proposal sent to Wash- ington in June would allow for cuts
in medical services to all children, the study concludes - not just
19- and 20-year-olds, as the state acknowledges.
That's because none of the plans the state is using as a model
for its new children's benefits package offers unlimited, preventive
and diagnostic medical care for children, as Medicaid does, the
analyses found.
"We wanted to get to this now, basically because there are a
number of similar proposals out there - Florida's, which has not
been submitted yet, and a concept paper from Georgia - that seek
major and important change to the Medicaid program," said Judy
Solomon, senior fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities. Solomon's analysis, "Risky Business: South Carolina's
Medicaid Waiver Proposal," will be the subject of a national media
call-in today.
Since South Carolina submitted its waiver in June, state Health
and Human Services Director Robbie Kerr has said he doesn't intend
to cut children's medical services. Under Gov. Mark Sanford's
direction, Kerr in June asked the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services for at least 30 waivers, or changes, to the Medicaid
program.
As legislators became aware last month that the waiver had been
sent to Washington without public input, some asked Sanford to
withdraw the request.
Medicaid, the 40-year-old medical safety net for the nation's
poor, is under pressure from the Bush administration to cut $10
billion from the ever-expanding program in the next five years.
A newly appointed commission is scheduled to make recommendations
to Congress on Sept. 1 on ways to make those cuts.
Sanford has been pushing for cuts to the program for more than a
year.
More than 52 million people get Medicaid in America. About
850,000 S.C. residents get the nearly-free medical services.
"The governor's proposal puts children's health at risk and it
imposes substantial new costs on South Carolina's most vulnerable
children, which will impede their ability to get needed health
care," said Joan Alker, senior researcher fellow at Georgetown's
Health Public Policy Institute.
Kerr said his proposal, which has touched off controversy South
Carolina, was designed to give Medicaid beneficiaries a sense of
responsibility and more choice in their health care decisions. |