Three years ago, the Legislative Audit Council recommended merging the
state Commission for the Blind with another state agency to improve
services and reduce costs. The Legislature's failure to do so should be a
reminder of how efficiencies continue to be lost by its resistance to
restructuring.
The LAC recommended merging the commission with the state Vocational
Rehabilitation Department, noting in its 2002 report that the agencies
have related goals and that a merger would eliminate duplication and
streamline services.
A recent follow-up on that audit showed some legislative interest in
the agencies' merger, but not enough actually to reach the goal. That
lapse offers an example of the Legislature's inability to get behind
broader restructuring reforms, both for state agencies and constitutional
offices.
The LAC didn't estimate an actual cost savings for the proposed merger,
but it did so for a larger consolidation involving eight health and human
services agencies that it recommended in 2003. That merger would have
produced savings of $26 million the first year, and improved customer
service as well.
Unfortunately, reform legislation failed to pass this year for the
health and human services agencies. Nor did a proposal to create a
Department of Administration to achieve greater accountability and
streamlining get legislative approval.
And the Legislature continues to falter on a proposal to allow voters
to decide whether several constitutional officers should be appointed by
the governor, and their agencies placed in his Cabinet. That proposal
would improve accountability by making the state's chief executive
officer, elected statewide, responsible for their operation. Many agencies
continue to be governed by appointed boards and commissions, unaccountable
to the voters.
Legislators like to talk about the importance of cutting costs and
reducing the burden on state taxpayers, yet have failed to advance
restructuring proposals that are clearly aimed at those ends. While some
legislators appear reluctant to support the governor's reform agenda, it
should be emphasized that the reorganization proposals for the Commission
for the Blind and for health and human services agencies came from their
own Audit Council.
The LAC's remarks on the restructuring of health and human services
agencies bear repeating. Noting that none were in the governor's cabinet,
the LAC concluded, "There is no central point of accountability for their
performance. No executive branch entity has the authority to ensure
comprehensive planning and budgeting or that services are provided
efficiently."
The LAC's follow-up report on the Commission for the Blind did conclude
that agency officials had approved a number of cost-saving and
accountability measures recommended in its 2002 audit. There's some
comfort in the thought that the bureaucrats are paying attention to ideas
for better government, even if many elected members of the Legislature
aren't.