S.C. must stop
encouraging our kids to smoke
SOUTH CAROLINA’S economic development strategy historically has
relied heavily on advertising our low taxes, and promising to make
them even lower for big businesses we’re trying to lure to the
state. Special deals that let industrial recruits lock in low
property rates for decades remain a key incentive we dangle before
them.
The strategy is born of the knowledge that setting a low tax rate
encourages people to engage in a behavior that is closely tied to
that tax rate.
Conversely, higher tax rates discourage behavior. That’s why
every business with a sales tax exemption starts screaming whenever
lawmakers talk about eliminating exemptions. It’s why we set our
alcohol taxes so high (although, judging from the number of people
killed by drunken drivers in our state, perhaps not high
enough).
Keep that in mind as the information sinks in that tax increases
in Kentucky, Virginia and now North Carolina have left South
Carolina with the lowest cigarette taxes in the nation.
This editorial board, along with just about everybody in the
state who cares about public health, has long argued that the
Legislature should increase the cigarette tax in order to discourage
kids from smoking. But frankly, we’ve had the argument all wrong,
and that’s clearer than ever now.
The issue isn’t whether the Legislature should take action to
discourage kids from smoking; it’s whether the Legislature should
stop encouraging kids to smoke.
That’s right: By clinging to their “no taxes” pledges, our
legislators and our governor are actively encouraging our children
to start smoking, to keep smoking, to doom themselves to lives of
addiction and lung cancer and emphysema and depression and anxiety
disorders. By trying to “protect” our tobacco farmers at the expense
of our kids (as if the amount of smoking done in South Carolina
makes any difference in the worldwide demand for tobacco), our
legislators and our governor are constantly adding to the $362
million a year the rest of us are already paying in taxes just to
provide medical care to the smokers who wind up on Medicaid. Not to
mention the other $650 million in medical care that’s provided to
smokers through private insurance (which is paid for by everyone who
has medical insurance) or by hospital emergency rooms, which aren’t
allowed to turn away people who can’t pay for their care, and whose
bills the rest of us ultimately pay.
It’s no coincidence that the state that long had the
fourth-lowest cigarette tax — and now has the absolute lowest — also
has the third-highest rate of teen smoking in the nation. That comes
out to 83,000 high school students in our state who are regular
smokers — with 11,200 more of them becoming daily smokers every
year. Half of those kids will die painful and costly deaths because
of their addiction — an addiction our state laws are
encouraging.
In a lot of cases, it would be great to be able to declare,
“We’re No. 1.” We’d love to be No. 1 in school test scores and
graduation rates and job creation and per capita income and life
expectancy.
But we’re not. Instead, our new claim to fame is our
bottom-dragging cigarette taxes. “We’re No. 1 in encouraging our
kids to kill themselves!” Not exactly the stuff of state
mottoes. |