BASE CLOSINGS POCESS Shaw touts its space to grow Base also promotes its role in homeland defense, its
location and its parallel runways By CHUCK CRUMBO Staff Writer
SUMTER — Vermont’s Green Mountain Boys could be flying to
the rescue of Shaw Air Force Base.
The Vermont Air National Guard has an F-16 fighter unit at the
Sumter base, ready to intercept a terrorist attack against U.S.
cities. Its presence underlines the need to keep Shaw open in the
post-9/11 world, advocates say.
“The homeland defense mission is a strong mission at Shaw,” said
retired Air Force Maj. Gen. Tom Olsen, who is spearheading Sumter’s
efforts to spare Shaw from the Pentagon’s budget-cutting ax. “Shaw
is well-positioned to cover the East and Southeast portion of the
United States.”
Despite that, some say Shaw is the most vulnerable military
installation in South Carolina heading into the 2005 round of base
closings.
The Sumter base’s predicament was summed up by Gov. Mark Sanford
while talking about efforts to protect S.C. bases. Shaw is “the spot
with the brightest light on it,” he said.
That light will continue to glare at least until May 16, when the
Defense Department recommends bases for closing.
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld has suggested that bases in the
United States could be trimmed about 25 percent, to 300. S.C.
leaders take Rumsfeld’s remark to mean almost all bases are at risk
of closing.
MONEY, JOBS AND HOMES
South Carolina is no stranger to base closings, losing
installations at Myrtle Beach and Charleston in previous
base-closing rounds.
What worries state and local officials is how closing Shaw would
hurt Sumter, including a 1995 projection that joblessness could
almost triple.
“I think we’d be impacted more than any other community in the
state,” said Sumter mayor Joe McElveen, an Air Force veteran once
stationed at Shaw. “We don’t have the immediate resources of a
Charleston or Myrtle Beach,” where local economies rely on
tourism.
A 1995 report predicted Sumter County joblessness — then 6
percent — would soar to 16 percent if Shaw were closed.
Today, joblessness is almost 11 percent in Sumter, where Shaw
accounts for about 20 percent of the total personal income earned in
the county.
Shaw’s influence on the Sumter economy is huge.
• Shaw’s annual economic impact on
the Sumter community totals $1 billion.
• Shaw is the county’s No. 1
employer, accounting for nearly 13,000 jobs, directly or
indirectly.
• Also, 60 percent of Shaw’s
airmen live off base. If the base closes and they leave, the housing
market would suffer depressed rents and prices, said USC research
economist Donald Schunk.
STAYING OFF THE LIST
Worries about Shaw’s future stem from its showing in the 1995
base-closing round.
Shaw was not on that list, but it ranked in the middle of U.S.
bases, touching off speculation that it would be a prime candidate
for future closure.
While the 2005 base-closing list is still being pulled together
by the Defense Department, Shaw already has made a “BRAC list”
compiled by Carlton Meyer, editor of the Web site g2mil.com.
Meyer, who published his thoughts about which bases should be
closed, included Shaw because it has excess capacity. Excluding the
temporarily assigned Green Mountain Boys, the base currently is the
home to only three Air Force F-16 squadrons.
The Air Force also has a motivation to cut costs. It needs to
close bases to pay for new weapons, such as the F-22 fighter, which
costs about $257 million per plane, Meyer said.
However, Meyer predicts Shaw could survive if the Air Force moves
at least one F-16 squadron from overseas back to Sumter.
Supporters say the Green Mountain Boys’ mission shows Shaw has
enough room for another unit and also enhances the base’s value to
the nation’s defense.
The Sumter community has spent the past decade trying to sell
Shaw to the Pentagon as a base that can take on more missions and
personnel.
Shaw is home to the 20th Fighter Wing, and its planes have been
in every major U.S. conflict since the base’s 1941 opening.
Most recently, Shaw’s fighters were deployed for the invasion of
Iraq. At the war’s height, Shaw had about 1,300 airmen deployed.
Shaw crews continue to go to the Persian Gulf. By May, 400 to 500
Sumter-based airmen will be in the region.
In addition, the 9th Air Force, which commands all U.S. air
forces in the Gulf region, is based at Shaw.
WASTE ‘NO TIME AND NO MONEY’
Time and money are two considerations weighing in Shaw’s favor,
said Brig. Gen. George Patrick of Gov. Sanford’s Military Task
Force.
Shaw pilots are within minutes of three training ranges.
Poinsett Bombing Range is just south of Shaw’s runways, allowing
pilots to simulate attacks. The Gamecock and Bulldog flying ranges —
large sections of airspace over the Pee Dee and northeast Georgia,
where pilots train — also are nearby, Patrick said.
South Carolina’s location along the coast also gives pilots
training space over the Atlantic that is out of the main flying
lanes for airliners shuttling between Miami and New York, Patrick
added.
Already, the Defense Department has said it will not give up
training ranges. Thus, Bulldog, Gamecock and Poinsett will continue
to be used after this year’s base closings.
Patrick contends moving Shaw’s fighters to another base — but
still having them train at the Georgia and S.C. ranges — would make
no sense. Flying from the new bases would cost the Air Force time
and money, said Patrick, chief of the S.C. Air National Guard.
“Do you and I want to pay at today’s prices for the jet fuel
required to drive from a base 400 or 500 miles away to get to
training air space, as opposed to a base that’s 10 minutes away?”
Patrick asked. “The advantage of flying tactical aircraft in South
Carolina is that you waste almost no time and no money getting to
the training.”
ROOM TO GROW
Supporters hope to turn one of Shaw’s weaknesses — its
underutilization — into a strength — offering space to grow.
Since his election in 1982, U.S. Rep. John Spratt, D-York, has
helped funnel about $88 million into Shaw to renovate and build more
facilities.
The construction has included improved housing, a new wing
headquarters, a dining room, an education center, even floodlights
for servicing aircraft at night. An $8.5 million deployment center
is under construction.
“Shaw’s an installation that could grow by 50 percent, and you
would not have to spend anything on military construction,” Patrick
said.
New or improved facilities do not necessarily ensure a base will
escape closing, said Christopher Hellman, director of the Project on
Military Spending Oversight. But they enhance a base’s stock if the
Pentagon is looking for places to move planes and troops without
having to pay for new facilities.
If base housing is being updated or new construction is under
way, that’s a plus as well. The military wants to improve the
quality of life for its troops so they will re-enlist, Hellman
said.
For example, Shaw is planning to build about 1,000 housing units
for military families through a public-private partnership.
“If your approach is to be a good neighbor and say to the
military, ‘How can we better work with you?’ — then that’s going to
have some resonance,” Hellman said.
Shaw’s other ace in the hole, Olsen says, is it is one of few
bases with twin, parallel runways. By operating two side-by-side
runways, Shaw can launch fighters twice as fast — a key factor in
the post-9/11 world in which the military needs to respond quickly
to threats like the terrorist attacks that struck the World Trade
Center and the Pentagon.
‘IT’S MAGICAL’
Another advantage, local leaders hope, is that a number of the
nation’s senior Air Force leaders once were stationed at Shaw.
For example, Air Force chief Gen. John Jumper and his deputy,
Gen. Michael Moseley, both are former 9th Air Force commanders.
Having friends in high places helps Sumter in getting its message
through to the Air Force leadership, Olsen said.
Col. Phil Ruhlman, the base’s current commander, says the
relationship between Shaw and Sumter is renowned in the Air
Force.
Ruhlman credits Sumter’s size, its Southern hospitality and its
military tradition with helping the Air Force feel at home. He
believes the feeling is mutual, noting that up to 50,000 are
expected to attend the Shawfest air show on April 23.
“I think we have a good relationship,” Ruhlman said. “If you want
to say it’s magical, well it is.”
Mayor McElveen, who also is honorary base commander, says any
obituaries for Shaw are premature.
“Everything we hear is pretty positive.”
Reach Crumbo at (803) 771-8503 or ccrumbo@thestate.com. |