Supreme Court
reverses fee award in gambling case
Associated
Press
COLUMBIA, S.C. - A video gambling company that
won its case against the state Revenue Department over advertising
does not deserve to have its attorney's fees paid, the state Supreme
Court said Monday.
The high court overturned a lower court ruling awarding $25,286
in fees to Video Gaming Consultants Inc.
The Circuit Court judge had said the company was due the money
because the Revenue Department "acted without substantial
justification when it continued to vigorously prosecute this case"
despite a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that would invalidate the
state's law against video gambling advertising.
The state Supreme Court said the agency "was in no position to
determine" the U.S. court's decision would make the state statute
unconstitutional. "An agency has no authority to pass on the
constitutionality of a statute," the court said.
Since the Revenue Department was justified in pursuing the case,
the justices wrote, there was no reason to award the gambling
company the fees.
South Carolina outlawed video gambling machines in July 2000. |