COLUMBIA — She entered the hotel ballroom slowly, her head
high, a small woman in a bright red suit, and let her adult daughter
and grandson take her hands as she came up the three steps to the
rostrum. The opposite wall was lined with TV cameras, and in the
three sections of seats, curious South Carolina citizens, both black
and white, drawn by the drama of her story, outnumbered the
reporters. Without a word being said, the applause rolled out, and
the spectators and journalists rose to their feet.
Essie Mae Washington-Williams responded with a nod of her head.
The 78-year-old, gray-haired great-grandmother, a retired
schoolteacher now acknowledged as the oldest child of the late Strom
Thurmond, a mixed-race product of his liaison at 22 with a
16-year-old black housemaid in his parents’ Edgefield home, appeared
to be entirely in control of her emotions. Three days earlier, she
had finally confirmed decades of rumors and told The Washington
Post’s Marilyn W. Thompson that she was in truth the daughter of the
longest-serving senator, who died earlier this year at age 100.
For a reporter who had watched Thurmond over a half-century, in
which he evolved from a staunch segregationist and fierce opponent
of civil rights legislation into the proud employer of a racially
integrated staff and a patron of historically black colleges, it was
an extraordinary moment.
For the people of this state, it was one more demonstration of
the strange and powerful ways in which the legacies of the past
impinge on the choices and emotions of the present.
That is a universal phenomenon, but in my experience, it is the
South, more than any other section of the country, that is haunted
by its past. The struggle to come to terms with it consumes more
psychic energy here than anywhere else I know.
At breakfast that morning, the mayor of Columbia, Bob Coble, told
me that two days earlier he had been in New York, doing what mayors
do in this time of high unemployment — talking to corporate
consultants about the advantages of bringing jobs to Columbia.
“I’m going to my first appointment,” Coble said, “and what do I
see on the marquee of the CNN building, where they have the news
bulletins going around in lights? The guy who burned the Confederate
flag down here has been barred from ever entering the state Capitol
again. That’s the image we have to fight.”
As almost everyone knows, South Carolina has been wracked by
ongoing controversy over the display at the Capitol of that symbol
of the Confederacy. The last two governors — one a Republican, the
other a Democrat — were turned out of office in part because of
their efforts to resolve the battle. An NAACP boycott of the state
is still in effect.
South Carolina has been struggling with an exodus of jobs. “We’re
winning the war in Iraq,” the mayor says, “but we’re losing to China
and India.” The last thing it needs is social strife that scares
away investors and employers.
Luckily, Columbia has a lot going for it. A new convention center
and hotel are under way. The university is expanding its research
center and is designated as a national center for fuel cell
development. The old warehouse district has been revived and looks
like Boston or San Francisco, with its apartments and
restaurants.
Into this melange of past controversies and hopeful prospects
stepped Essie Mae Washington-Williams. Had she spoken with anger
about the hypocrisy of a man who espoused separation of the races
but exploited a powerless young black woman sexually, she could have
stirred the racial tensions never far below the surface. Instead,
she spoke kindly of her father’s outreach to her and the financial
support he provided. She seemed entirely sincere in saying that she
had kept her silence about her parentage all these years out of
respect for him — a debt the senator’s other children acknowledged
last week by their ready acceptance of her claimed paternity and her
friendship.
The sense I got from members of both races who came to the hotel
was one of pride — and of relief. When this model of tact and
discretion said that telling the world who she really is made her
feel “completely free,” they applauded. And when she said she had
come back from her longtime residence in Los Angeles to South
Carolina to make her first public appearance as the daughter of the
former governor and senator, because “‘my roots are here,” they
cheered.
For the moment, at least, they were not blacks or whites, they
were South Carolinians, able to acknowledge and deal with their past
— and the reality of their complex history and heritage.
Mr. Broder’s e-mail address is davidbroder@washpost.com.