If Gov. Mark Sanford is really serious about pushing maximum
power downhill to S.C. local governments, he might want to take a
look at the hog-farm bill passed last week by the S.C. House. If the
S.C. Senate also passes the bill, the state's 46 county councils
will lose their home-rule authority to regulate animal farms - most
conspicuously, corporate hog farms of the sort that rendered parts
of North Carolina an environmental war zone in the 1990s.
The bill, sponsored by Rep. Billy Witherspoon, R-Conway, wipes
out all present and future local efforts to regulate large
hog-farming operations. State regulations would apply uniformly
statewide.
That would be fine if the state rules, as adopted by the S.C.
Department of Health and Environmental Control with close
legislative oversight, were sufficiently stringent to guarantee that
toxic hog waste will never pollute waterways and that hog stench
won't render adjacent rural areas unlivable. But they're not.
That's why five S.C. counties, including several in the Pee Dee,
have used home-rule authority to attack those problems - thereby
prompting the corporate-hog lobby to petition Witherspoon and other
agriculture-friendly legislators to take that authority away. Their
concern is that some county rules were so restrictive that large
farms could not be located there.
We understand these concerns and have some sympathy with House
Speaker David Wilkins' concern that "our agriculture industry ought
to have solid regulations that they can rely on."
But local concern about protecting residents' quality of life are
equally valid. Not for nothing did Horry County Council go on record
against the bill, for fear that it would disrupt local zoning and
planning efforts.
The hope must be that the S.C. Senate - the proverbial saucer
that cools the passions that boil over from the cup of the House -
recognizes that this is a bad bill and kills it. If not, Sanford
will have to get out his veto pen.