State to fall to
last in SAT Tenenbaum releases early
report showing 3-point drop in scores By BILL ROBINSON Staff Writer
South Carolina’s average SAT score will rank last among the 50
states when a nationwide report on 2004 college entrance exam
results is made public next week, the state education superintendent
said Friday.
Inez Tenenbaum disclosed how S.C.’s latest high school graduates
measured up on the test as a preemptive move that she acknowledged
was motivated by concern the performance could become an
election-year issue.
“It’s unfortunate that people will delight in seeing scores go
down,” said Tenenbaum, who predicted the three-point decline in the
test scores will be fodder for campaign ads criticizing her.
Tenenbaum is the Democratic party’s candidate for the U.S. Senate
seat held by Fritz Hollings, who retires this year. Her opponent is
Rep. Jim DeMint, R.S.C., from Greenville.
DeMint’s campaign manager told the Associated Press Friday the
drop in SAT scores is not a political issue. “Let’s find a way to
fix it,” Terry Sullivan said.
Tenenbaum said the average SAT score for the class of 2004, which
graduated this spring, was 986 compared to 989 a year ago. The 2003
national average was 1,083; the maximum score is 1,600.
“It’s the first time in six years we’ve had a dip,” she said.
Her decision to talk about the drop in scores before next week’s
announcement triggered a response from Gov. Mark Sanford, whose
staff requested a briefing from the association that owns the
test.
Sanford called the latest results “unacceptable” and took the
opportunity to promote school reform proposals that have yet to gain
support from the Legislature.
“Whether it’s charter school reform or our ‘Put Parents in
Charge’ (voucher) proposal, this administration is going to continue
pushing for fundamental reforms to the current system that give
parents more choices and kids more opportunities,” Sanford said
through a spokesman. “We’re also going to continue our efforts to
bring about real funding reforms and Cabinet-level accountability at
the Department of Education.”
Paul Krohne, director of the S.C. School Boards Association,
called the score decline “a glancing blow, not a knockout
punch.”
“I hope this doesn’t add fuel to the fire to those interested in
dismantling the good things we have going on” in public schools,
Krohne said.
The SAT report posted the year Tenenbaum took office in 1999 was
954, which ranked South Carolina at the bottom of the nation.
In the intervening years, scores made what Tenenbaum and her
deputies characterize as “historic” gains — until this past
year.
“There is not really one factor you can pinpoint” as the cause of
the decline, Tenenbaum said.
She said the 2004 average score would place South Carolina 50th
among the states, a blow to leading education advocates who pledged
in 1998 that the state’s school system should be ranked among the
nation’s top 25 by 2010.
“I don’t think we have to over-react to it,” Tenenbaum said.
SAT results are among several ways educators gauge academic
achievement and progress toward long-range goals.
The state Department of Education will release preliminary
results from Palmetto Achievement Challenge Tests next month that
Tenenbaum said will show an improvement over scores from 2003. PACTs
are given to students in grades three through eight and test
material taught in math, English-language arts, science and social
studies.
Over the past several years, South Carolina students who have
taken national standardized tests have performed on par with, or in
some cases, above their peers in other states, Tenenbaum noted.
The 3-point drop in the state’s average SAT score
notwithstanding, Tenenbaum said South Carolina can boast it has
produced the nation’s best rate of improvement on its average score
over the past five years.
She declared a net 32-point gain during her 5½-year tenure as the
state’s top education policy leader “the good news.”
Colleges and universities use SAT scores as a factor in admission
decisions. Some describe it as a way to predict whether a student
will have a successful freshman year.
Unlike PACTs, which are mandatory, high school students take the
SAT voluntarily, and pay $29.50 to do so.
The annual report on SAT scores comes each August from the
College Board, a private company that owns the test. It has strict
rules about when the information can be made public.
After learning news organizations were working on reports about
test results before the official release date, Tenenbaum said she
conferred with the College Board to alert it that she was going to
divulge the statewide average.
Details of district-by-district and individual high school scores
will be announced Tuesday.
Tenenbaum speculated the decline could be linked to the fact 133
more seniors a year ago took the test than their counterparts in
2003.
Tenenbaum said the state faces no consequences from the College
Board over her decision to reveal the state’s average score.
“It’s an ethical issue,” she said.
Asked if she thought stories circulating about the test-score
decline were politically motivated, Tenenbaum said, “it’s not the
first time a leak occurred in South Carolina,” adding “it’s unfair
and unethical.”
Sanford spokesman Will Folks said no one from the governor’s
office released the information and noted representatives of several
agencies attended the briefings. Folks said Sanford plans to talk
with Barbara Nielsen, one of his advisers, about the reason Nielsen
invited an employee of the S.C. Policy Council to attend the
briefing.
The organization is a conservative research organization
Republican lawmakers look to for guidance in crafting laws and
public policies.
Efforts to reach Nielsen and Ashley Landess, the Policy Council’s
spokesperson, were not successful.
Reach Robinson at (803) 771-8482 or brobinson@thestate.com. |