South Carolina's General Assembly
opens a new session today with the potential to do more harm than good.
One of the biggest drives of the session will be to funnel public money
into private schools. That would harm public schools that need every ounce
of support they can get. Through tax credits to parents and scholarship
donors, Gov. Mark Sanford would encourage citizens to leave public schools
behind, which would be a terrible mistake.
To say that public schools need
competition -- like textiles need competition from China -- is a common
argument that comes up empty. Public schools already have competition. Our
community has a number of healthy private schools and many parents
home-schooling their children. But it remains the public school system
that is the measure of the community, and they need support, not
detractors from within the Statehouse.
Private schools sprouted like mushrooms all over South Carolina as soon
as integration belatedly became the order of the day. Has that competition
improved public schools in Jasper County or Clarendon County, for example?
No. Public schools do not get better when good students leave, and it
would be counterproductive to write that into state law.
The legislature also should be careful with how it revamps the rules
for Senate debate. There may be room for change, so that the Senate is not
where about 100 bills go to die each session. But the system has worked
fairly well for many years and the Senate is not supposed to be the home
of fast-track legislation, like the House is. It could do more harm than
good to speed up the "deliberative body."
Tort reform is another major change expected be debated in this
session. That, too, could do more harm than good. The debate must be
framed on facts, not anecdotes. Legislators must dig deep enough to find
the true reasons for soaring medical malpractice insurance rates and a
lack of doctors in some communities. They must find the true impact of
malpractice costs on total health care spending. And, most of all, the
legislature should do nothing to abridge the rights of the people to
redress wrongs done against them.
Taxation will be on the agenda, with a number of suggestions on ways to
change the current system. The governor wants to lower the state income
tax rate. Legislators are solidly behind change to the local property
taxes that are hitting many citizens hard as property values soar.
Whatever changes are made must be made in a coordinated manner. Lowering
one tax could only make another rise. Piecemeal change doesn't work in the
long run. Any changes must be constitutional, and they must be fair to
people of all income brackets.
The legislature could do more harm than good by tinkering with
environmental protections or by usurping the rights of local governments
to make local decisions.
Legislators must have the wisdom to discern when it is best to leave
well enough alone.