DEVELOPMENT
Officials question
S.C. tax breaks Conservation deals
spur probe By John O'Connor and
Gina Smith Knight
Ridder
COLUMBIA - State and federal tax
officials are investigating whether S.C. landowners are getting
inflated tax breaks for agreeing not to develop property.
A conservation easement is a legal agreement that allows land
owners to deduct the developed value of the land from their taxes.
In exchange, they agree to permanently cede development rights to a
nonprofit group that monitors the land and ensures it is not
developed.
The S.C. Department of Revenue and the Internal Revenue Service
will audit easements this tax year after Congress raised questions
about the practice last year.
Neither agency said it knew how widespread illegal or fraudulent
claims might be in South Carolina.
But Burnie Maybank, director of the S.C. Department of Revenue,
said he thinks some S.C. developers are writing off swamp and marsh
where homes could never be built or claiming land values equivalent
to those of the nation's best real estate.
The department recently completed an audit of 51 conservation
easements, a total of 32,000 acres, donated over a three-year
period.
It found that property owners had estimated a value of $255
million on donated land though not all of that value was claimed on
tax returns.
By comparison, the state collected about $420 million in
corporate taxes in that period.
"We were shocked by the amount of money" involved, Maybank
said.
Maybank thinks the problem is increasing. He cited a growing
number of sham nonprofits set up by developers to accept easements.
A nonprofit has to agree to accept an easement before a tax credit
can be claimed.
An N.C. company on its Web site urges golf courses to secure
easements on their fairways, which Ann Jennings with South
Carolina's Congaree Land Trust said is an example of an easement
that does not conserve land for the public.
Fraud is a problem, preservationists said.
"The government is cracking down, and they should," said Yancey
McLeod, an environmental consultant who lives in Richland County and
does conservation work across the country.
"There have been some abuses," McLeod said.
Supporters say easements help protect streams, forests and
wetland while another use allows families to reduce estate taxes and
keep large parcels of land within a family - though development will
be limited.
Conservation easements were first approved by Congress in 1980 as
a way to encourage preservation of environmentally important
land.
In exchange for giving up development rights, the property owner
can claim the land's developed value, minus the remaining land
value, as an income tax deduction.
Those deductions can add up, and experts said conservation
easements are becoming more popular as people become more familiar
with the law.
"The easement business is booming," said Ken Driggers, who helps
write conservation easements.
Driggers also is executive director of the Palmetto Conservation
Foundation.
"Ninety-nine and nine-tenths of all easements are good
conservation projects and above-board," he said. |