COLUMBIA, S.C. - The state Highway Patrol has
no legal authority to charge other state agencies for traffic
control at special events such as football games, Attorney General
Henry McMaster says.
The Department of Public Safety began examining ways to charge
for the service this summer after Gov. Mark Sanford vetoed a line in
the budget that prohibited the patrol from charging for traffic
control.
But, in an opinion dated Sept. 4, McMaster wrote that a court
would likely find any fees imposed by the Highway Patrol in
violation of state law.
"We have located no statute which currently authorizes the
Highway Patrol to charge a fee unilaterally for law enforcement and
public safety assistance at special events," McMaster wrote. "To the
contrary, such services are specifically required to be performed by
the Patrol pursuant to existing state law."
The opinion, which does not carry the force of law, won't
prohibit the Department of Public Safety from charging fees. The
agency has no firm plans to charge fees but is looking into a system
for charging, said spokesman Sid Gaulden.
The opinion was sought by Senate President Pro Tem Glenn
McConnell, R-Charleston. McConnell wrote in a letter to the attorney
general that courts have found that an agency has only those powers
specifically granted to it by law. McConnell said the budget veto
could be interpreted by other agencies as a "green light" to set
their own fees.
"You cannot put any executive agency in a position where they
have the power to tax," McConnell said. "I felt like you could only
charge a fee if the General Assembly authorized it. I think this
clarifies it."
Sanford spokesman Will Folks said the governor respects the
opinion of the attorney general but that taxpayers shouldn't pick up
the costs associated with special events.
"The governor continues to believe, however, that in these
economically challenging times, the taxpayers of South Carolina
shouldn't foot the bill for hundreds of state troopers directing
traffic at football games," Folks said.