LOCAL Updated: 06/28/05
Ten Commandments win partial OK
Federal ruling prompts local criticism

STORY TOOLBAR
Email This Article Print This Story
Speak Out! Subscribe To Print
By Andrew Dys The Herald
Though area county courthouses don't have the Ten Commandments hanging publicly, the U.S. Supreme Court decision Monday to bar hanging them at Kentucky courthouses has some upset.

Rep. Greg Delleney, R-Chester, said the "liberal" five justice majority in the Supreme Court is "destroying the Constitution."

"This court is hostile to religion," Delleney said.

Delleney pushed bills twice in the past four years that would have allowed displaying the Ten Commandments at the Statehouse and other public buildings. Both times the measure passed the House but died in the Senate.

Rep. Gary Simrill, R-Rock Hill, another sponsor of the failed South Carolina measures, said he hopes to try again in January.

In another case from Texas, a 5-4 Supreme Court majority ruled Monday that a 40-year-old, 6-foot granite marker at the Texas capitol could stay because it was both historical and religious in nature.

Monday's rulings end the particular cases but don't decide what can and can't be done elsewhere, said Andrew Siegel, a University of South Carolina law professor. Both sides claimed victories Monday, he said.

"Religion is a touchy, emotional issue," Siegel said. "This is an area where we will likely see more litigation."

Courthouses housing criminal, civil and family courts in York, Chester and Lancaster counties do not have Ten Commandments displays, said clerks of court for each county.

Most preachers and churchgoers in conservative South Carolina would approve of posting the Ten Commandments in courthouses, said Mike O'Dell, director of missions for the York Baptist Association.

"The Ten Commandments are the bedrock of our society," O'Dell said.

The decision may even spark a sermon this Sunday from the Rev. Mike Lowery, pastor at Rock Hill's West End Baptist Church. The commandments are God's standard that people should try to attain, Lowery said, and justices should not try to lower that standard.

"This decision grieves me," Lowery said. "Our country is founded on religious principles. The Ten Commandments are all over the Supreme Court building itself. It is kind of hypocritical for them to rule like they did."

Some say that the high court rulings are the right way to keep government out of religion where it has no place to begin with.

"A true conservative doesn't want government meddling in his religion," said Rauch Wise, a South Carolina lawyer who has argued cases on behalf of the American Civil Liberties Union. "The rulings allow for displays in a historical context. But it keeps government out of a person's life and religion. Government is supposed to be neutral on religion, and this decision keeps it neutral."

Andrew Dys •329-4065

adys@heraldonline.com

We Apologize...
In an effort to provide our readers with additional tools and features, our forums will be temporarily unavailable while we perform maintenance and upgrades. We apologize for this inconvenience.

-Heraldonline.com Staff
More Headlines
Ten Commandments win partial OK - 06/28/05
Officials split on value of costly addition - 06/28/05
Council backs Saluda Road homes - 06/28/05
Deployment changes local soldier's mind on Iraq war - 06/28/05
Woman accused in shooting death released on bond - 06/28/05
Campaign hopes to cover costs of new books for libraries - 06/28/05
In Brief - June 28, 2005 - 06/28/05
Family mourns shooting victim - 06/27/05
Annexation swells Tega Cay's limits - 06/27/05
Clover officials to hold final vote on tax increase - 06/27/05
Principal to bring 'consistency' to role - 06/27/05
In Brief - June 27, 2005 - 06/27/05
Former JROTC leader Davis driven by passion for big planes - 06/27/05
S.C. safe from Supreme Court ruling - 06/26/05
Former Indian Land athletes found dead - 06/26/05
Fort Mill misses shot at honor - 06/26/05
Ham operators fine-tune technique to turn hobby into service Radio fans hitch a ride on airwaves - 06/26/05
Accelerating gas prices can fuel frustration for commuters - 06/26/05
WSOC-TV to cover implosion of Charlotte Convention Center - 06/26/05
In Brief - June 26, 2005 - 06/26/05
Grant artwork plans incomplete - 06/26/05
- 06/26/05
Something very different - 06/26/05
C'mon, tell me ... am I fat? - 06/26/05
Big vision, big price tag; Projected costs Projected revenues - 06/26/05
S.C. safe from Supreme Court ruling - 06/26/05
No 'All-American' title for Fort Mill - 06/25/05
South Pointe High readies for first back-to-school - 06/25/05
Rock Hill district comes to aid of nursing shortage - 06/25/05
Rock Hill motorist dies in crash - 06/25/05
City plans night of fireworks, food, fun during patriotic fest - 06/25/05
City, county budgets include pay raises, property tax increases - 06/25/05
Priest marks 25 years with resolve to forge ahead - 06/25/05
WSOC-TV to cover implosion of old Charlotte Convention Center - 06/25/05
In Brief - June 25, 2005 - 06/25/05
Families joined by daughters' diseases United to help - 06/24/05
S.C. lawmakers: Ban would pass with relative ease - 06/24/05
Gas prices inch higher as July 4 nears - 06/24/05
Four teens charged in armed robbery - 06/24/05
Couple to attend Graham's final crusade - 06/24/05
Fort Mill bypass construction faces delay due to bridge work - 06/24/05
Fort Mill student, local volunteer honored for artistic contributions - 06/24/05
Is Fort Mill ready to be identified as an ... All-America City? - 06/23/05
Bond denied in '03 hotel shooting - 06/23/05
Buford teenager drowns - 06/23/05
Area peach farmers quick to help amid loss of their own - 06/23/05
York names temporary schools chief - 06/23/05
Vietnamese community reacts to leader's meeting with Bush - 06/23/05
In Brief - June 23, 2005 - 06/23/05
In Brief - June 23, 2005 - 06/23/05
Hey, Fort Mill: This isn't your everyday YMCA - 06/22/05
Bearcats' Ringer to retire - 06/22/05
Robertson requests stay of execution - 06/22/05
Fascination with 'Walker' rains down on York spectators - 06/22/05
Former professor's latest book examines fallen Colombian drug cartel - 06/22/05
Budget increase pleases recreation leaders - 06/22/05
In Brief - June 22, 2005 - 06/22/05
Warriors want to build on 2003 success - 08/26/04
QUICK CLICKS
Shopping Buy and sell anything and everything in one stop.
Shopping Shop our retail newspaper ads online.
Sports Your online source for sports news in the area.
Buzzies Click here to vote.
York County Magazine Your guide to the York County area.