Child advocates
want more access to list of suspected abusers
Associated
Press
COLUMBIA, S.C. - Child advocates want the
state to make its list of suspected child abusers open to the
public.
The state Department of Social Services maintains a list of about
37,600 names of people who judges or social services investigators
say probably abused or neglected a child, but most parents can't use
it to check out their neighbors, coaches or teachers.
Individuals on the Central Registry for Child Abuse and Neglect
have not necessarily been convicted of a crime, making it difficult
to grant public access to the list, said Denyse Williams, executive
director of the American Civil Liberties Union of South
Carolina.
"It would be subject to constitutional challenges," Williams
said. "You would be putting some people who have not been convicted
in a position to be deprived of certain opportunities without due
process."
Paula Owens, an Upstate child advocate, said that means many
admitted child abusers can keep their secret to themselves. "They
can't do this," she said. "They can't hide these people."
Tricia Reese, a Columbia parent who said her daughter was
neglected in a day-care center, wants better access to the list.
"The fact that it's not public record just really bothered me
because people have a right to know," Reese said.
Created by state statute in 1981, the registry began as a
database of child abuse cases.
Through a series of amendments to the law, it gradually became a
list of perpetrators in substantiated abuse cases, said Virginia
Williamson, general counsel for Social Services.
Until amendments in 1997, individual Social Services caseworkers
were authorized to place individuals on the list. Now, only Family
Court judges or Circuit Court judges can place people on the list
and are required to do so in serious cases of substantiated abuse
and neglect.
Someone is placed on the list once an allegation is "founded" or
"indicated."
Licensed day-care centers are required by the state to use the
registry to screen applicants before determining whether they should
be allowed to work with children.
Prospective foster parents must be screened against the registry,
and some school districts refer to it when hiring teachers and
support staff.
In all, the agency receives about 5,000 requests each month to
check a person's name against the registry, said Mary Williams,
director of the division of human services at the department.
Any person can check a name against the registry, but only with
the written consent of the person they are checking.
State Rep. John Graham Altman, R-Charleston, who chairs the
General Laws subcommittee of the House Judiciary committee, said he
does not foresee any changes in the near future in the way the
registry is set up.
Altman, an attorney who has represented defendants in criminal
sexual abuse cases, said he would advocate for the list to be public
if he felt confident that everyone on the list deserved to be
there.
South Carolina is not the only state with a child abuse
registry.
The National Clearinghouse on Child Abuse and Neglect Information
says 42 states log child abuse complaints in a central registry. No
states make their lists public, according to the clearinghouse.
But Howard A. Davidson, director of the American Bar
Association's Center on Children and the Law, said South Carolina's
process is different from most other states because accused
offenders elsewhere can make their case before a judge or appeal
being placed on the list.
---
Information from: The State, http://www.thestate.com/ |