Legislators
ill-serve state by refusing to ban teen smoking
IT’S AGAINST THE law to sell or give cigarettes to minors, yet 36
percent of the high school students in South Carolina smoke. That’s
more than 50 percent higher than the national average.
We know that nearly all of those kids will become lifelong
addicts. We know that 90,000 S.C. kids currently younger than 18
will die prematurely because they became lifelong addicts. We know
that even those who don’t die prematurely will suffer from lung
cancer and emphysema and depression and anxiety disorders — and add
to the $307 million a year the rest of us are already paying in
taxes just to provide medical care to the ones who wind up on
Medicaid.
And yet what have we done to try to stop this?
Practically nothing — despite the fact that there are simple,
obvious steps our state could take to reduce the number of kids who
smoke, steps that have been demonstrated in other states to
work.
We could invest in anti-smoking programs that make smoking seem
uncool, from the media campaigns that have worked in other states to
our state’s own innovative Rage Against the Haze teen-to-teen
program, which seems to be exciting officials everywhere except in
South Carolina. But that costs money, and so legislators,
unaccustomed to investing now for huge payoffs later, aren’t
interested.
We could raise our embarrassingly low cigarette tax, and price
some kids out of the market — again, a strategy that has been proved
to significantly reduce teen smoking. But that might make cigarette
manufacturers and smokers mad, and it might violate those absurd “no
new taxes” pledges that far too many legislators have mindlessly
signed, and so legislators aren’t interested.
We could even reduce teen smoking by ... making it illegal for
kids to smoke. But that — well, we can’t even think of an irrational
objection, but still our Legislature hasn’t done it.
Amazing as it sounds, it is not illegal for kids to purchase or
possess cigarettes in South Carolina. Most kids probably don’t know
this. But they do know that no one they know has ever been arrested
for smoking; change that, and you might make a few kids think twice
about taking up smoking.
The House passed a bill that makes it illegal for minors to
purchase or possess cigarettes, just as we do with alcohol. It even
added those changes to a second, broader bill designed to reform the
Medicaid program that provides free medical care to all the former
teen smokers who burned out their lungs and hearts and everything
else. And then the measure was added to another bill. But the
stand-alone bill died in the Senate Judiciary Committee, where it
had been since March 4 — 2003. The other bills died on the Senate
calendar.
Then one of those galling things that happens all too frequently
at the State House happened. The Senate — which had been sitting on
the measure for more than a year — voted unanimously to attach it to
a related bill bill headed back to the House.
And the House refused to go along.
Thus, each body can claim it tried to pass this simple bill to
keep a few of our kids from killing themselves. And legislators in
both bodies will continue to play games like this with our
children’s lives for as long as we sit quietly back and let
them. |