Gov. Mark Sanford gave lawmakers a mid-session reminder of his
restructuring agenda Wednesday using a horse and buggy to underscore how
outmoded the state's system of governance remains. Given the
intractability of some legislators, he might have used a mule instead.
The governor has made a compelling case for giving the state's chief
executive more authority over state government. While some gains were made
during the administration of Carroll Campbell, the governor still has
authority for less than 20 percent of state government.
Following a comprehensive study of state government by a citizens
committee, which included numerous statewide hearings, the governor
recommended broad changes, including the appointment by the governor of
most constitutional officers who are now elected.
Mr. Sanford has since trimmed that list to include the superintendent
of education, secretary of agriculture, secretary of state and adjutant
general. He would have the lieutenant governor run on a ticket with the
governor. Those changes would require a vote of the people, and the
Legislature first has to authorize a statewide referendum.
In addition, he has sought broad restructuring of health agencies as
part of his Cabinet and the creation of a Department of Administration.
Much of state government continues to operate under the oversight of
legislatively appointed boards and commissions, and the Budget and Control
Board, of which the governor is one of five members.
As House Speaker David Wilkins observed in response to the governor's
press conference, that body has made advances on the governor's agenda
since the current session got underway. He cited passage of legislation
for constitutional officers restructuring, income tax reduction, tort
reform and charter schools.
Rep. Wilkins tersely urged the governor "to roll up his sleeves and
work diligently with the Senate to pass these important legislative
initiatives already passed by the House."
The governor is attempting to do just that by drawing public attention
to the status of restructuring and urging legislators to accomplish more.
Mr. Sanford's style may not be as collegial as that of his predecessors,
but he knows how to make a point.
South Carolina has been a legislatively dominated state since passage
of the 1895 constitution, and the structure of government has not changed
sufficiently in response to changing times. State government would be more
accountable and efficient if the governor had the responsibility to
actually serve as chief executive. Unfortunately, the governor is
hamstrung by a cumbersome system that diffuses authority and creates
unnecessary expense to the taxpayers.
While there have been legislative reform initiatives this year, Mr.
Sanford doesn't believe they go far enough. For example, the House
approved a bill that would have a referendum affecting only two
constitutional officers. And the House and Senate bills to create a
Department of Administration still leave much authority in the hands of
the state Budget and Control Board. The governor's office cites a health
care restructuring bill in the Senate that doesn't include two essential
agencies: the Department of Disabilities and Special Needs and the public
health component of the Department of Health and Environmental Control.
Mr. Sanford has demonstrated his ability to cut costs and improve
service in the Cabinet agencies where he has authority. Improvements have
been noted, for example, at the Commerce Department, Corrections and the
Department of Park, Recreation and Tourism. None stands out in such
contrast as the Department of Motor Vehicles, which the governor has
transformed since taking office.
Incidentally, the governor's use of the horse and buggy harkens to Gov.
Campbell's inauguration speech of 1991, when he said, "Failure to
restructure government, failure to bring horse-and-buggy government into
the space age, will perpetuate a system that answers to nobody, listens to
nobody and serves nobody other than its own special interest."
That was true in 1991 and, notwithstanding some progress under Mr.
Campbell's administration, the same remains true today. It is past time
for the Legislature to advance the governor's restructuring agenda.