Raid appalling, but
not example of criminal act
WE CONCUR with state Attorney General Henry McMaster, who says
there is much to be learned from a drug raid last year at Goose
Creek’s Stratford High School. Mr. McMaster recently concluded that
the raid broke no laws. It is hard to question that decision. Any
criminal charges filed against the officers involved would have been
difficult to prosecute, certainly. And there is every indication
that Mr. McMaster seriously and thoroughly investigated the
matter.
The attorney general spent eight months looking into the raid. He
reviewed the legal paper trail, including information from
interviews and investigations by the State Law Enforcement Division
and the 9th Circuit Solicitor’s office. The attorney general
personally visited the corridor where more than 100 Stratford
students had been held at gunpoint, some of them handcuffed. The
nation was appalled by images of the scene, captured on the school’s
own videotaping system. They include threatening, drug-sniffing dogs
and at least one officer with his gun pointed directly at the
students.
It has since been learned there are additional surveillance
camera recordings of the day, which the school district did not
release. Berkeley County Solicitor Ralph Hoisington told the
Charleston Post and Courier that the additional footage shows
officers handcuffing children who appeared to be complying with
officers’ orders. That contradicts what the newspaper found in the
Goose Creek Police Department’s official report, which said 10 or 12
students were restrained for failing to comply with officers’
orders.
In addition, it has become clear since the Nov. 5 incident that
the Goose Creek Police Department violated its own policies in
allowing the dogs to search the children. The students should have
been moved out of the area before the dogs sniffed lockers,
bookbags, jackets and the like.
Despite the lack of any criminal prosecution for the events of
the day — that includes against the students, by the way, as no
illegal drugs were found — the fallout from the raid is ongoing.
Longtime Stratford High School Principal George McCrackin
resigned and was reassigned to a district post. Civil lawsuits on
behalf of some of the children held in the hall are pending. The
Berkeley County School District has revised its policies concerning
student searches, including a directive that physical contact
between dogs and students be avoided. The Rev. Jesse Jackson has
traveled to South Carolina to rally on the students’ behalf, and
some of them even appeared on the Montel Williams show questioning
their treatment. It is safe to say the whole matter hasn’t burnished
South Carolina’s reputation a bit.
Perhaps there will be those who will call Mr. McMaster’s response
insufficient. However, he expressed extreme frustration with the
officers’ behavior, calling it “grossly inappropriate.”
That it was, and we can only hope that nothing like it is ever
seen in the school halls of our state, or any other. |