In these most difficult times when budgets are short and needs
are great, we at the S.C. Chamber of Commerce are pleased that there
is one important area of consensus. Political leaders of both
parties acknowledge the need for adequate Medicaid funding.
The reason is simple.
Medicaid is a necessity for our state's most vulnerable citizens.
While Medicaid serves senior citizens and the poor, it also provides
health care for more than 40,000 uninsured children, for tens of
thousands of blind and disabled people, and thousands of families
who have children with special needs including disabilities or
chronic illness. It is also the lifeline to health care for the
working poor.
Yet, our Medicaid system has become as chronically ill as many of
the patients it assists.
Recent tight budget years and the escalating costs of health care
have created a woefully under-funded Medicaid system. Temporary
fixes, such as last year's $100 million appropriation from one-time
money, only compound the problem for this year and future years. Not
only do we under-serve those who qualify for Medicaid, we pass the
unpaid costs on to those fortunate enough not to need Medicaid. And
we do all of this in a world where the federal government is willing
to give us $3 for every $1 we commit to Medicaid funding.
Answers are never easy, especially in a world where budgets are
tight for both governments and families. And, true solutions --
those answers that solve problems for the long-term -- require
innovative thinking and leadership.
We have seen leaders of both parties and the private sector
searching for those solutions. The thinking has been innovative.
Taxpaying citizens and companies have boldly asked for a dedicated
funding stream, most particularly an increase in the taxes on
cigarettes. House members, under the leadership of Speaker David
Wilkins, have sought ways to reduce Medicaid costs by eliminating
waste and increasing efficiencies. And Gov. Mark Sanford stepped
forward last week with a plan that provides additional Medicaid
funding while stimulating the economy with a corresponding tax
decrease. It is a long-term solution for a chronic problem, and it
shows promise.
The governor's plan is simple in concept but multi-faceted in
implementation. He supports an increase in the cigarette tax,
coupling it with a gradual decrease in personal income tax. He sees
the personal income tax reduction as an economic stimulus, an offset
for the increased cigarette tax and, quite frankly, the delivery of
a campaign commitment.
It appears in concept to deliver all that and perhaps more.
In addition to a dedicated funding stream for Medicaid, the plan
starts the state along a road where personal income tax rates --
affecting all individuals and most small businesses and sole
proprietorships -- will be lowered to the uniform tax rate of 5
percent. It accomplishes that by using a portion of the annual
personal income tax revenue growth above a baseline to fund a tax
credit. If the economy is not growing, the credit is not available.
In other words, the governor's plan is designed to share the wealth
with citizens, but not to create additional pain by costing
government when revenues are not available.
It makes every individual and every small business a stakeholder
in South Carolina's economy. Grow the economy -- create wealth for
our citizens -- and you will share in it. It is gradual and relies
on growth. It keeps government growth in check during good times. It
recognizes income taxes as an important component of any balanced
tax system. And it avoids tax shifts to taxpayers not receiving the
credit.
The debate on the governor's proposal began the day it was rolled
out. That is healthy. As chaotic as legislative debate might appear,
it often is a messy route to a strong solution. Details will be
attacked and debated. Ideas will be accepted and dismissed. In the
end, more often than not, what emerges is a stronger product. The
governor's proposal will have to travel that road. But we all owe
him a genuine "thank you" for his leadership in placing an
innovative, comprehensive solution on the table. It deserves careful
and serious consideration now.
Mr. Howard is president and chief executive
officer of the South Carolina Chamber of Commerce.