House subcommittee
passes school tax credit bill
PAMELA
HAMILTON Associated
Press
COLUMBIA, S.C. - A proposal to give tax breaks
to parents paying private school tuition passed a House subcommittee
during a hastily called meeting Thursday, a day after supporters and
opponents spoke for hours at a public hearing on the bill.
The legislation passed without amendment on a 3-2 vote, split
along party lines. The meeting was called after the House adjourned
in the morning. The bill now heads to the full Ways and Means
Committee.
The legislation - dubbed Put Parents in Charge - would allow
parents whose children transfer from public schools to independent
schools, home schooling or other public schools to receive a tax
credit. Based on this year's state budget, the tax credit would be
about $2,000 per child in the fall.
Subcommittee members heard public comment in a crowded room on
the Statehouse grounds Wednesday from more than 30 people, including
Gov. Mark Sanford and Education Superintendent Inez Tenenbaum, who
opposes the bill.
The bill is a key part of Sanford's legislative agenda. "It's
something we certainly hope continues to move forward through the
process and the governor will continue to push for it," Sanford
spokesman Will Folks said Thursday.
Lawmakers also heard from a few parents at Wednesday's
hearing.
"A lot of folks on both sides have strong feelings about it,"
said Rep. Chip Limehouse, R-Charleston, one of three of the bill
sponsors who backed the bill. "But one thing's for certain in South
Carolina, our educational system is not serving our students or our
parents currently. This measure is just an effort to place market
reforms in education."
On Wednesday, Hollie Bennett, whose has three children in Rock
Hill public schools, told legislators that the school "are failing
in educating our children because we do not address the
individuality of student learning."
"Public schools are accountable to the government," Bennett said.
"And this has gotten us where? Last, that's where."
Another parent, Leni Patterson, who also is a school board member
in Laurens County, said the bill would take money away from public
education.
"In our public schools, we teach citizenship," Patterson said.
"We teach what it means to be one part contributing to the whole of
society. We don't teach them that if they don't like part of
government, then they shouldn't have to pay for that service."
Subcommittee chairman Shirley Hinson, R-Goose Creek, and Rep.
James McGee, R-Florence, joined Limehouse in voting for the bill,
while Democratic Rep. Gilda Cobb-Hunter of Orangeburg voted against
it and Rep. Alex Harvin of Summerton was not present but sent a
letter saying he intended to vote against the bill.
"We're very disappointed that the subcommittee has taken this
action," Tenenbaum said Thursday. "It's a very bad piece of
legislation that would have dramatic effects on the funding of
education in South Carolina.
"We hope that we can stop this in the full Ways and Means
Committee and are working very hard to try to stop it."
Subcommittee members said they expected several amendments to be
added to the legislation once it moves to full committee.
McGee was considering an amendment that would limit the credit to
parents whose children transfer from failing or unsatisfactory
schools. Limehouse was considering one that would allow all parents
to get a tax break, not just those who make less than $75,000 in
taxable income.
Cobb-Hunter was considering amendments, including one to require
private schools to meet similar standards for public schools laid
out in the Education Accountability Act.
"I am still very much opposed to the legislation, but will offer
amendments in committee addressing some of the glaring holes in this
bill - like the lack of accountability," Cobb-Hunter said. |