EDITORIAL
Gut It Up on Free
Pour, Legislators Let liquor
distributors, wholesalers both deliver big bottles to
customers
Oh swell. It may be the end of the year - even later - before the
reign of the minibottle comes to an end in South Carolina. Over in
Columbia, the state's liquor wholesalers and distributors have been
scratching and clawing over which side should be empowered to
deliver liquor to bars and restaurants. Rather than settle the
catfight themselves, S.C. legislators apparently prefer to wait
until the distributors and wholesalers settle their differences on
their own.
Because vast sums of money are at stake, that likely won't happen
soon. Never mind that S.C. voters in November expressed a
clear desire to allow bar and restaurant owners to pour
drinks from big bottles, should they desire to do so. Never mind
that minibottle-size jolts of alcohol contribute to the state's
unacceptable drunken-driving rates.
Here's the problem: Neither wholesalers nor distributors deliver
liquor to bars and restaurants now. Current S.C. law requires bar
owners to pick up their minibottles at liquor stores with federal
wholesale licenses - an unreasonable burden in counties, such as
Georgetown, that have no licensed wholesaler of their own.
As The Sun News reported this week, the distributors see
themselves as the natural entity for exclusive delivery to bars and
restaurants. They already have fleets of trucks, now in use to
deliver minibottles to the wholesalers' liquor stores. Why, they
wonder, should wholesalers be empowered to buy delivery trucks of
their own when they, the distributors, can easily handle that
job?
The wholesalers, not surprisingly, see the distributors' argument
as a ploy to cut them out of the brave new world of free pour. They
argue, accurately, that the four companies that distribute liquor in
South Carolina don't individually carry all the liquor brands that
bars and restaurants sell. So they, the wholesalers, are in a better
position to provide drinking establishments with the exact liquors
their owners wish to sell to customers.
Tom Sponseller of the S.C. Hospitality Association has the right
personal take on resolving this catfight: Allow wholesalers and
distributors both to deliver liquor to bars. That, he says,
would create more competition - always a good idea.
Some other Hospitality Association members, says Sponseller, are
willing to wait to see how the fight comes out. Their chief interest
is in receiving liquor deliveries from someone so they no
longer have to pick up liquor themselves.
But waiting for distributors and wholesalers to come to their
senses seems dangerous to us. They might never agree on the
liquor-delivery issue. Given legislators' unfortunate propensity to
kowtow to these liquor-based special interests, the result of
waiting could be a free-pour law that doesn't include delivery.
Led by the Grand Strand delegation, legislators should gut it up
and authorize wholesalers and distributors both to deliver
liquor to customers. The market should decide which liquor-based
special interest handles the job better. More important, legislators
should fast track a complete free-pour enabling bill to passage in
time for this year's tourism season. Forcing South Carolinians to
wait until 2006 for the free-pour law they authorized in 2004 should
not be an
option. |