ANYONE WHO doubted there was a new sheriff in town should have
been disabused of that notion last week when Gov. Mark Sanford
handed down his first budget vetoes.
With a few easily overlooked strokes of the pen, Mr. Sanford put
legislators on notice: Business as usual is no longer sacred. It's
not even safe.
As bold as his moves to preserve trust funds and quash "wish
list" spending were, those weren't what made the vetoes
revolutionary. That came when the governor dug deep into the bowels
of the budget and pulled out eight "temporary provisos" and a
handful of minor spending items for elimination.
There's nothing new about a governor vetoing spending items or
provisos, which tell agencies how to operate for the year the budget
remains in effect. What's new is excising anything other than new
programs or newly added provisos -- in other words, interfering with
the way business has always been done. And Mr. Sanford did precisely
that, in order to spell out some of his values about government and
budgeting, by removing items that have:
- Allowed the State Museum to provide free office space to its
foundation. Mr. Sanford noted that this provision, added in 2000,
was "inconsistent with the manner with which other foundations are
expected to reimburse the state for the use of facilities."
- Allowed the State Museum to collect the state admissions tax,
like all other amusements, but to keep the money for itself -- in
other words, to charge a higher admission price but claim part of it
was a "tax" beyond its control. Again, he cited inconsistency.
- Protected from any budget cuts the per diem payments to members
of the Agriculture Commission. Mr. Sanford said the per diem rate
"should be subject to the same prioritization process as other
expenditures when an agency is forced to reduce its budget."
- Prohibited the Highway Patrol from charging to provide traffic
control at football games, festivals and other "special events."
Eliminating this proviso, which has been buried in the budget since
1993, does not require the Patrol to start charging for this
service, although it should once it has a chance to establish
procedures.
- Essentially required state agencies to fill out the tons of
what has often become meaningless paperwork in order to comply with
the Baldrige management doctrine. Mr. Sanford noted that, like
previous management crazes to sweep the private and public sectors,
this one tends to "cultivate reliance upon a 'one-size-fits-all'
management approach irrespective of the size or function of the
agency." He would prefer that managers spend their time and money
developing "the conceptual understanding to run dynamic
organizations and serve the public effectively."
- Exempted the money the State Museum and the Budget and Control
Board pay the state for "rent" from calculations of any
across-the-board cuts. These exemptions, the governor said, are
"inconsistent with the manner with which across-the-board cuts are
administered within other agencies."
- Required that the main entrance to the State House garage
"shall be accessible from any direction except for the 4:30 pm to
5:30 pm time period during which time traffic is routed in one
direction out of the facility" and that the exits on Assembly Street
"shall be open for traffic from 4:00 pm to 6:00 pm." Mr. Sanford
said this provision "unduly micromanages an administrative function"
and "affords no flexibility to deviate from specific hours of
operation for the statehouse parking garage for special events,
holidays, weekends or disasters."
- Given $119,000 in special funding to motorcycle safety programs
the Legislature required tech schools to run. Mr. Sanford said that
program should be funded through tuition or general funding "as
would be the case with other technical college programs."
- Provided $60,000 to run Leadership South Carolina, which he
said "should be funded exclusively by the participants and/or their
organizations."
One of the worst things policymakers in our state do, year in and
year out, is to assume that everything government does is essential
and that everything is being done in the best way possible. Oh,
lawmakers talk a good game about shaking up the bureaucracy,
trimming the fat; but even the starve-government Republicans have
done precious little to challenge this assumption since they came to
power.
Until now. Partially because he's an outsider with no investment
in the way things have always been done, partially because he is
more willing than the typical politician to make waves, Mark Sanford
is working to overturn that idea. He has taken it on in fits and
starts throughout the year, vetoing a handful of status-quo bills as
they landed on his desk.
But to actually delve into established practice and start undoing
those parts of it that don't make good sense is something we haven't
seen from a governor. And something we could stand to see a lot more
of.