COLUMBIA - President Bush's plan to let
more Hispanics legally work in the United States drew conditional
support from some Midlands employers.
The employers said Bush's temporary worker program, announced
Wednesday, might help them find more workers for hard-to-fill jobs
in construction and meat processing.
But a state labor leader said many Hispanics will shun a program
they perceive as a tracking method because of its three-year limits
with undefined renewal provisions.
Others said Bush was motivated in part to bolster support among
Hispanics in his bid for re-election this fall.
South Carolina had an estimated 36,000 illegal immigrants in 2000
- up dramati-
cally from 7,000 in 1990, a U.S. Citizenship and
Immigration Services study says.
Their illegal status gives employers more power.
"If they're no longer considered illegal, I would hope it would
be more difficult for the unscrupulous employers to take advantage
of them," said Maria Smoak, director of Hispanic Ministries for St.
Peter's Catholic Church.
Smoak, who left Cuba as a child in 1960, said she is questioned
daily by Hispanics hoping for an amnesty program that will allow
those here illegally to become legal residents.
Most Hispanics in the Midlands are from Mexico, the 2000 census
shows. In years past, Hispanics were often migrant farm workers, but
now, most want to settle and raise their children in the area, Smoak
said.
Many work in construction or poultry processing plants, while
some have started their own businesses.
"They're basically here for the same reason: Hope for a better
economic future and a better life for their family," she said.
Alan Kahn, chairman of M.B. Kahn Construction of Columbia, said
he would support a plan that helps him find more skilled workers
without putting Americans out of work.
"The only time it would be fair is if they were filling jobs that
could not be filled now," Kahn said.
Kahn's company employs more than 500 workers and generates $250
million to $300 million in sales each year. Some of his workers are
Hispanics, but he didn't know how many. He said he hires based on
skills, not a willingness to work for less pay.
About 85 percent of the 750 workers processing chickens at
Columbia Farms are Hispanic, so company officials will look closely
at Bush's proposal, said Jim Mabe, manager of the West Columbia
complex.
"We feel it's a very positive step in the direction of a more
fair and sensible documentation policy. It could be very helpful in
matching willing workers with good jobs that are not taken by U.S.
citizens," Mabe said.
Labor unions have been split.
Donna Dewitt, president of the S.C. AFL-CIO, said Bush is trying
to mollify countries in Central and South America seeking trade
concessions while reducing the security threat posed by an
uncontrolled flow of illegal immigrants.
But many Hispanics fear signing up for three years of legal
residency will expose them to deportation when their legal status
expires.
"A lot of them are going to see this as a tracking method," she
said.
Some higher-paid craft unions are worried about the influx of
illegal workers willing to work for less, while some retail and
service unions have been organizing Hispanics and pressing for
amnesty programs to remove the fear of deportation.
"If they're here illegally, they're afraid to get their rights,"
Dewitt said.
Some unions want policies that allow more Hispanics to become
residents, while farm workers would like a program to let workers
cross the border more easily for seasonal work, Dewitt
said.