Better Than
Nothing Roads proposal would divert
money from other programs
The General Assembly's top money man has done an admirable job of
showing South Carolinians how enough money might be scraped together
to repair the roads they drive most. House Ways and Means Committee
Chairman Bobby Harrell, R-Charleston, this week proposed that about
$90 million per year be diverted from other public purposes and put
into maintenance and improvement of state-owned secondary roads.
Its enactment into law would create a $90 million hole in the
state's general fund budget. Secondary-road improvements, in other
words, would come at the expense of other state agencies and
programs.
We understand, even appreciate, the Republican mind-set against
raising taxes and fees for any reason. But what would be wrong with
asking highway users to cover more of the direct costs that their
vehicles exert upon S.C. roads and the S.C. environment, via a
local-option gasoline tax or higher vehicle-registration fees?
Especially considering that Harrell and other Republican leaders are
considering giving away more of the state's tax base via Gov. Mark
Sanford's proposed income-tax cut, it seems nonsensical to reduce
the general fund even more to take care of secondary roads.
If this is the best the General Assembly can do, the Harrell
measure is worthy of passage, in a nose-holding sort of way. But if
his proposal becomes law, no one should pretend that it's the result
of visionary
lawmaking. |