By Kyle H. Wilkins
I am the shadowy figure behind the frosted glass reception
window. For the past four summers, I have interned at an orthopedic
surgeon's office. As an intern, I have worked a myriad of positions:
patient check-in, medical records clerk, insurance and billing.
On occasion, I must refuse service to people unable to pay for
care. My best advice is to visit the emergency room or apply for
Medicaid. Those solutions are part of the problem -- a health system
increasingly unable to cope with rising costs and an aging
population. Transparency and shared responsibility are necessary
reforms; Health Savings Accounts are the solution.
I have answered hundreds of calls from patients confused about
their bills. Few patients clearly understand their insurance
coverage; fewer still understand how medical offices and insurers
calculate and pay medical bills. Doctor offices have whole insurance
departments to decipher the insurance claims mess.
Every patient demands the best care at the best price (read: no
out-of-pocket costs). Patients see the newest medication or
diagnostic test on the television and come into our office demanding
it. Hypochondriacs cost everyone money. With medical reimbursement
rates so low, doctors are willing to oblige. The high costs of
running a medical office, maintaining training with Continuing
Medical Education credits and rising malpractice insurance rates
stifle the medical profession.
Advertisement
|
 |
Expectation of unlimited care through health insurance or the
government has created a crisis. Patients feel entitled to care
regardless of their ability to pay. HSAs are a great way for
patients to save for health costs without tax penalties. Where I
work, we have always given discounts to patients who had to pay for
care themselves. These patients often take a more concerned approach
to their care and health costs. With an aging population, it makes
sense to allow people to save money for future health problems
without tax disincentives or the need to rely on the government for
often partial care.
HSAs encourage people to save money, spend wisely and choose
their own practitioner. But is it wise to treat a trip to the doctor
like Wal-Mart? Why not. Instead of wastefully spending insurance
money to get an extra brace so that your accident insurance will pay
out more money, health consumers will buy what they need. Choice
lowers costs.
The days when consumers rely solely on insurance for all their
costs are at a close. Rising costs from misuse of services and
increasing demand make health insurance a heavy burden for American
companies.
Recent legislation made HSAs easier to obtain, but they are not
available to all Americans. Last year, a third of all HSA recipients
had incomes below $50,000, and a third of small businesses offering
HSA insurance plans had never previously offered insurance for
employees. President Bush proposed that the government should make
it easy for low-income families to purchase an HSA plan by making
tax credits available to these families. Every person has a vested
interest in their health and should save for the unexpected and the
routine.
Concerns that HSAs will increase health-care costs should be
addressed. Doctors have a responsibility to ensure that patients
receive proper care and do not forgo a necessary operation.
Furthermore, HSAs will not replace insurance. Instead, the savings
accounts will allow consumers to set aside money to pay for costs
not covered by their plans, such as glasses and medical equipment. I
have dealt with multiple patients at the office who have canceled
surgeries because they cannot pay their deductible. That would not
be a problem if they had an HSA.
The lure of free care has created an imbalance. HSAs must be
economical to work. Americans should save for health care better
than they do for retirement. To work, HSAs should be coupled with a
decrease in Medicare benefits for rising generations to provoke
savings.
Medicare, which will run out of funds in 2020, is unable to adapt
to a changing America. Can Medicare handle 78 million baby boomers?
No. But if we make HSAs widespread, middle-aged workers can
"catch-up" and set aside extra tax-free savings and decrease the
burden. Because insurance carriers can charge lower premiums, the
long-term effect of HSAs is that insurance becomes more affordable
since people pay only for what they need.
Consumer driven health care has the potential to transform how
Americans are treated. Cost consciousness will decrease waste, lower
costs and remove the opaque window separating patient and doctor.
Every American should have access to health care. HSAs will help
make that possible. |