S.C. prisoner
details tax fraud scheme worth millions
FREDERIC J.
FROMMER Associated
Press
WASHINGTON - A South Carolina prison
inmate told a rapt House panel Wednesday about how he defrauded the
U.S. government of $3.5 million by filing bogus tax returns.
The man, an anonymous 37-year-old inmate dubbed "John Doe,"
testified behind a partition to prevent him from being photographed
or videotaped during the House Ways and Means subcommittee on
oversight hearing.
He said he started out by filing phony returns for 10 inmates in
1991, which netted $4,200 to $5,400. He kept a $1,000 commission on
each return.
"Over the years, I filed six to seven hundred returns," Doe said.
"The total dollar amount would be approximately $3.5 million, face
value," of which he netted $600,000 to $700,000.
Doe said inmates spent most of the ill-gotten tax return money to
buy illegal drugs.
"The money and drugs eventually lead to beatings, stabbings and
extortion," he said. "With the money I personally made, I often
looked out for poor or indigent inmates who got no help from home."
But he conceded he also used the money to buy sneakers, a color TV
and "lots of drugs."
The Internal Revenue Service estimates that 15 percent of all tax
fraud is committed by prison inmates.
"Tax fraud in any form is unacceptable and illegal," said the
subcommittee chairman, Rep. Jim Ramstad, R-Minn. "But it is
particularly outrageous when it is committed by prison inmates while
they are behind bars."
In the typical scam, the inmate fills out a tax form with phony
income and withholding information, and then claims a large
refund.
Nancy J. Jardini, chief of criminal investigation at the IRS,
said one obstacle to cracking down on the problem is a section of
the IRS code which prevents the agency from disclosing tax
information, with a few exceptions.
"None of the exceptions permit the IRS to refer refund fraud
information to prison officials for the imposition of administrative
sanctions," she said.
J. Russell George, the Treasury Department's inspector general
for taxation, said IRS figures show that the number of fraudulent
tax returns filed by prisoners quadrupled from 4,300 in 2002 to
18,000 last year.
"Of particular concern is the fact that the IRS frequently pays
refunds on returns it has identified as fraudulent," George said.
"In 2004, the IRS paid 36,000 refunds on returns that it determined
to be fraudulent; 4,100 of these were issued to prisoners."
Doe, who is serving a 25-year sentence for burglary, grand
larceny and arson, said he will have to serve five years in federal
prison for tax fraud. He said the practice is widespread, based on
conversations he's had with friends in other states. |