Testimony raises
new issue in HomeGold bankruptcy case
By JIM
DuPLESSIS Staff
Writer
ANDERSON — A former HomeGold manager who left the company
in 2002 ordered corporate documents destroyed five weeks ago,
including some seen only by the highest-level executives, witnesses
testified in federal court here Tuesday.
Former HomeGold executive vice president Tony Park is among the
nearly two dozen defendants in a lawsuit filed last fall by the
trustees appointed by the U.S. Bankruptcy Court to recover some of
the $350 million owed to investors, suppliers and others.
The trustees have been sifting through literally tons of
documents seeking evidence after the March 2003 bankruptcy filing.
But trustees did not know until last month that Park had stored
thousands more documents in a mini-warehouse in Greenville.
They found out after the man Park hired to dump the documents
contacted HomeGold’s lawyers. The whistle-blower kept some of the
documents, which he turned over to HomeGold lawyers, who in turn
contacted the State Law Enforcement Division.
At stake are million of dollars HomeGold is seeking from Emmco, a
company formed a few months before HomeGold’s bankruptcy by its
former chief executive, Lexington businessman Ronald J.
Sheppard.
HomeGold’s lawyers tried to link Park to Sheppard and have asked
U.S. District Judge G. Ross Anderson to punish Sheppard’s current
mortgage company, Emmco, by making the Lexington company
automatically liable for damages. The only question in a trial would
be how much Emmco would have to pay.
In order to rule against Emmco, Anderson said, HomeGold’s
trustees must show the documents destroyed would have been used as
evidence. He will hear closing arguments on the issue April 15.
Anderson said it appears documents were destroyed. “I don’t want
anybody playing games with the federal court, especially this one,”
he said.
Among the documents recovered were daily cash reports, which one
former HomeGold manager said were highly confidential. Anderson said
he would look closely at the daily cash reports, and he asked
lawyers to find out when those reports started and what happened to
them.
It was unclear from testimony whether the report that Park had
was a duplicate or part of the mass of missing information from
HomeGold.
James Brazeale, who worked as a loan officer for HomeGold in 2001
and Park’s Mortgage Exchange from April 2002 until its collapse in
December, said he recalled visiting Park at his home last year and
Park implying he had information damaging to Sheppard on a computer
diskette.
“He held up a disk and said, ‘I have Ronnie right here,’”
Brazeale said.
Sheppard hired Park in 1999 to work for Sheppard’s HomeSense
mortgage company. After HomeGold bought HomeSense in May 2000 and
appointed Sheppard chief executive, Sheppard put Park in charge of
running loan offices in Greenville and Lexington and opening a loan
office in Cincinnati.
Park testified he received documents and computers in late 2001
after he left HomeGold to start Mortgage Exchange, a competing
company in Greenville. Park said he was given permission to take the
documents and equipment by Forest Ferrell, HomeGold’s president
until its bankruptcy a year ago.
Park testified that he was not trying to hide information from
HomeGold’s trustees. He said he wanted the documents out of his
storage facility before they were seized because he was unable to
pay the bill.
He said Ferrell also granted him $250,000 in severance pay in
return for agreeing not to hire away HomeGold’s loan officers.
“The perception was I would take most of the loan office,” Park
said. “He basically authorized me to launch the business so it would
succeed.”
Mortgage Exchange folded in December, and in February, Park asked
a contractor to get rid of the files and equipment.
Sheppard, who was chief executive and Ferrell’s boss, testified
that he did not authorize Park to take computers or documents and
that he did not know beforehand that he would do so.
“I was told Forest Ferrell, who is deceased, authorized Park to
take the documents,” Sheppard said.
But other witnesses said Park told them he had received the
documents and computers from Sheppard. Park testified that Sheppard
came to Mortgage Exchange last year to help Park close some
loans.
Testimony by Karen Miller, a chief financial officer who worked
seven years for HomeGold, disputed Park and Sheppard’s contention
that Ferrell agreed to give Park computers, loan files and cash to
set up a competing business.
Miller said the daily cash reports were highly confidential,
given regularly only to Sheppard, chairman Jack Sterling and the
chief financial officer.
Park’s own testimony appeared to clash. He said some of the
non-loan documents recovered after he ordered them tossed were
documents he carried to New York in 2000 to help persuade its chief
lender not to pull $50 million in loans.
Later, he said he didn’t know how far in debt HomeGold was.
“You didn’t have a financial statement?” Anderson asked, noting
that information was in public documents on the Internet.
“When you work for Mr. Sheppard, you work at what’s in front of
you,” Park said. “Your head’s down. It’s kind of like being in
battle.”
Reach DuPlessis at (803) 771-8305 or jduplessis@thestate.com |