House rejects
cigarette tax increase Horry County
leaders voted against bill By
Zane Wilson The Sun
News
COLUMBIA - All seven of Horry County's
House members voted with the majority Tuesday to slap down a 32-cent
cigarette tax increase.
The county is the biggest tobacco producer in the state, but
opponents of the increase said it was not just about protecting
tobacco, it was about not imposing a tax increase.
The tax, atop the existing 7 cents a pack, was expected to raise
$115 million to be used for health insurance for poor children and
other health services.
Proponents of the increase said the state should cease to have
the lowest-priced smokes.
"I'm tired of us being last in all the bad things," said Rep.
Doug Jennings, D-Bennettsville.
He said he is from a tobacco-growing county and it is hard to
take such a stand but "it's the right thing to do."
"It's not the right thing to do. It's a recipe for disaster,"
said Rep. Tracy Edge, R-North Myrtle Beach.
The proposed health care expenditures were in areas his
subcommittee oversees.
Cigarette tax income is not stable, and new services should not
be added that depend on the money, he said.
Rep. Jim Battle, D-Nichols, said he is in the tobacco business
and does not think a tax increase on cigarettes is fair. High-fat
food also causes health problems and no one was proposing a tax
increase on such meals, he said.
The cigarette tax increase, discussed for most of the legislative
session, went down 67-46, although it could come up later in a
separate bill.
And it is likely to come up again when the Senate debates the
budget.
The vote came on a motion to delay work on the tax-increase
amendment to the state budget, so a yes vote was a vote against the
cigarette tax increase.
Rep. Vida Miller, D-Pawleys Island, and Rep. Carl Anderson,
D-Georgetown in favor of the tax increase.
"I think eventually it's going to come, but I don't think this is
the place for it, in the budget," said Rep. Billy Witherspoon,
R-Conway.
Witherspoon said cigarette sales have gone up in South Carolina
since Georgia and North Carolina raised their cigarette taxes. That
means more money for South Carolina, he said.
Besides, the state has more revenue than it expected, "so why
raise taxes on anything?" Witherspoon said.
On other budget matters, final approval of $1 million for
Interstate 73/74 planning and $2 million for a new matching tourism
promotion fund did not come up for final approval.
A $5 million allocation for beach renourishment should come up
for approval today, with Horry County scheduled to get about half of
it.
Edge expected difficulty selling the allocation to colleagues
even after Gov. Mark Sanford said he did not put his hometown,
Sullivans Island, in the budget to get the other half of the
money.
Sanford's budget set aside $5 million for beach renourishment in
coastal communities. It did not mention a location.
However, the state agency that oversees beach renourishment has
Sullivans Island listed with Horry as the next in priority.
Edge said members are skeptical that Sanford did not know that
when he put the money in his budget request.
Sanford has vetoed beach renourishment money until this year.
|