School choice bill
stirs debate about racial equality
JENNIFER
HOLLAND Associated
Press
COLUMBIA, S.C. - The simmering debate over
school choice in South Carolina ran into the lingering issue of
racial equality Thursday as black leaders pledged to fight a bill
that would give tax credits to parents who send their children to
private schools.
The measure has become a contentious issue long before it is
expected to be taken up in a committee.
A discussion between state NAACP President Lonnie Randolph and
Rep. Thad Viers, R-Myrtle Beach, turned into a nearly nose-to-nose
shouting match in the crowded lobby of the Statehouse.
Viers approached Randolph about the NAACP's economic boycott of
the state set in place until the Confederate flag is removed from
Capitol grounds.
"Call off your boycott and more money can go into our education
system," Viers said.
Randolph said the boycott was a separate issue from funding
education and accused the lawmaker of making "bigoted comments."
"Is that the only counter to education in this state ... to say
that I'm racist?" asked Viers, who is white.
Randolph, who is black, replied: "If the shoe fits, wear it."
Minutes before the encounter, members of the state chapter of the
National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and black
lawmakers said the legislation would take resources away from public
education.
"It is a move back to segregating schools," said Rep. David Mack,
D-North Charleston, who is chairman of the Legislative Black
Caucus.
Mack also said he was concerned about money being pumped into the
state to pay individuals to take a position against public
education.
"There are groups running around that's made up of leadership in
the black community that is very much misguided on this issue," Mack
said. "We at the South Carolina Legislative Black Caucus - we are
not for sale."
Supporters of the bill say South Carolina ranks at the bottom of
many education rankings and something needs to change. The bill
would allow parents the option to transfer their children to
different public schools, send them to charter schools, parochial
schools or home school.
"It opens up a discussion there needs to be reforms in the
education system," said the Rev. Richard Davis, who is executive
director of Clergy for Education Options.
Davis, whose group advocates for minorities, said he was
disappointed that race was dragged into the debate.
"When you play the race card it becomes very sensitive, people's
emotions get riled up and they don't even want to look at the bill,"
Davis said.
Winthrop University political science professor Scott Huffmon
said it's no surprise the debate turned to talks about race.
"Race is inextricably linked to socio-economic status, especially
in the South," Huffmon said. "It shows just how deeply entrenched
these issues are in South Carolina society."
Randolph said the best solution to the achievement gap between
black and white children is to treat them fairly and change the way
the state pays for education.
He said the state relies on property taxes to pay for schools and
minorities have poor-performing schools because they often live in
low-income areas.
"The leadership of this state has never sat down and listened to
the other side's complaint. They only respond to pressure," Randolph
said. "The structure of the state is to keep black children
behind."
Gov. Mark Sanford has pushed the bill as a way to take politics
out of the education system and replace it with the power of the
marketplace.
The Republican governor's spokesman Will Folks said school
district lines have been drawn through black and white
communities.
"The system has done a fairly capable job, sadly, of segregating
itself," Folks said. "That's why we believe parents in largely
minority, low-income parts of the state are receptive to school
choice." |