IN YOUR
HOMES
Combating mold in Carolinas It has taken over the S.C. Governor's Mansion. It
displaces families and ruins heirlooms. It costs $50,000 to $100,000
to clean up even a modest home. By Colin Burch The Sun News
COMMON QUESTION
Mold has chased the Ewings from their Loris home.
Everything inside is essentially ruined, covered with toxic mold
spores distributed through the air conditioning system.
Caroline Ewing cried for months. "You feel like you've lost your
home and your history - we have lost our history," she said.
South Carolina's humidity creates mold-related problems for
homeowners - problems that can't be measured by existing
governmental health guidelines and generally aren't covered by
insurance. Mold even forced Gov. Mark Sanford and his family to bail
out of the Governor's Mansion while crews undertake a remediation
project that could exceed $1 million.
"The Governor's Mansion has brought it back to the forefront,"
said Tom McHood of A&I Fire and Water Restoration.
Whether mold problems are actually becoming more widespread is
unclear.
Experts have different theories.
Part of the reason mold has become more of an issue could be the
way buildings are constructed, said Richard Bennett, a certified
industrial hygienist and chief science officer with Risk Tech LLC,
an environmental-health services company in South Carolina that is
cleaning up the Governor's Mansion.
"After the energy crisis in the 1970s, we sealed our buildings
up," he said. That's a good thing from an energy-conservation
standpoint, but "when water goes into a building now, it can't get
back out and it doesn't dry quickly," he said.
Fred Newby, a Myrtle Beach attorney who specializes in
construction cases, said, "I don't know if this is a new problem or
our testing methods have gotten more sophisticated."
Either way, fixing the problem is expensive.
A full cleanup of even a modest residential home could run
$50,000 to $100,000 or more, Bennett said.
That's what the Ewings are facing.
Back in July 2003, Caroline Ewing had trouble sleeping,
experienced itchy eyes and had other symptoms.
An out-of-state mold inspector found toxic varieties of mold in
their home. The spores had been distributed through the air
conditioning system, and covered everything, including heirlooms and
kitchen pots.
Mold-contaminated items must be cleaned before they are moved
into a new or decontaminated living space, but the cost to
decontaminate it can exceed the value of the property itself, and
homeowners insurance policies don't cover most mold problems.
Insurance companies see most mold-related problems as maintenance
issues rather than acts of God.
The Ewings haven't made a final decision on what they'll keep and
clean. Meanwhile, they're living in a second house, making two house
payments, two utility payments and digging into their savings,
Caroline Ewing said.
Spores and symptoms
Research on mold's health impact is ongoing, and there are no
federal or state guidelines for the amount of mold spores acceptable
in residential air.
Industrial hygienists usually do the evaluation of the number of
mold spores inside a home or office. They typically compare the
species of mold inside to what naturally occurs outside the
building.
Certain creatures, including stachybotris and penicillium, are
more likely to cause health problems, but the effect of a mold
problem on someone's health isn't predictable based strictly on the
number of spores in the air.
"It really affects some people more than others," said Steve Kahn
of Full Steam Ahead Fire and Water Restoration.
If a test finds a high level of toxic spores in a home, the
hygienists or remediation experts might recommend the homeowner
leave the house.
Dianne Minasium, program coordinator in the S.C. Health
Department's Bureau of Air Quality, said that, because there are no
governmental guidelines, DHEC doesn't do inspections or testing.
The best DHEC can do is point people to the Environmental
Protection Agency's information, available at EPA.gov/mold. DHEC
will mail the same information in brochure form to people who do not
have Internet access.
The EPA encourages homeowners to clean a mold area of less than
10 square feet in size. Harder surfaces can be cleaned with
detergent and water, but must be dried thoroughly. More permeable
surfaces might have to be removed altogether.
But if the moldy area is larger, the EPA recommends a
professional cleanup service.
The problem for homeowners is that standard homeowner insurance
policies don't cover mold remediation, although Full Steam Ahead's
Kahn said so-called HO6 condominium policies typically will cover
mold.
Some insurance companies are offering mold riders that can be
added to existing single-family home policies for an extra fee, but
the payouts are capped, usually less than $10,000.
In South Carolina, Nationwide's homeowner policy includes up to
$5,000 coverage for mold remediation, but only if the mold developed
as a result of a type of water damage that already is covered in the
policy, said spokesman Kevin Craiglow.
Jane Swanson, who lives in the River Hillls subdivision of Little
River, takes Tylenol Sinus while she waits for her house to be
fixed.
"I sort of have problems with drainage and allergies, and my
husband noticed this musty smell," said Jane Swanson, who lives in
the River Hills subdivision of Little River.
The Swansons had Clean Space of the Carolinas inspect their crawl
space, where the company discovered a mold and mildew problem and
presented the evidence in digital photos.
The couple accepted an offer from the company to clean up the
area and line it with a heavy-duty, waterproof liner to prevent
future problems. Clean Space says it's easy for the mold spores
under the house to be drawn in the house.
The cleanup, encapsulation and dehumidifying process will cost
more than $5,000.
"I can't wait to get it done because it's going to take care of
all this," she said.
How mold gets in
Local mold remediation companies say mold problems are
particularly common in second homes that are unoccupied for extended
periods.
Usually it's water damage left unattended that allows mold to
grow, said Kahn of Full Steam Ahead Fire and Water Restoration.
Culprits include incorrect flashing around windows, bad drainage
on air conditioning units and overflowing drain pans on
refrigerators.
Cleaning, paying, reselling
Professional remediation is essential for many reasons, said
McHood of A&I Fire and Water Restoration.
"It creates a liability issue if you sell the house, and the mold
comes back," McHood said.
South Carolina and most other states require the seller of a home
to disclose "all material facts," and that includes mold problems,
said Tom Maeser, president of Fortune Academy, a local real estate
school.
The N.C. Association of Realtors includes on its Web site
guidelines from the National Association of Realtors, which say in
part that sellers should disclose "mold-related conditions, water
intrusion and presence of known existing or past mold [other than
that which is known not to adversely affect the property or its
occupants]."
Keeping moisture out
The key to prevention is controlling humidity and moisture in the
home, but techniques will differ between the crawl space and the
rest of the house, local experts said.
"They automatically think of mold as plumbing leaks," said Sandy
Poe of Red Flag Home Inspections. "In our area, the big problem is
people having their homes shut tight."
Poe recommends running the kitchen and bathroom fans, especially
when owners are away for extended periods of time.
Crawl spaces need almost the opposite of the living space, said
John Fisher of Clean Space of the Carolinas.
Building codes have required crawl space ventilation, but Fisher
said recent research shows ventilation is creating problems.
Humid air, entering crawl space vents, doesn't just flow through,
Fisher said.
The degree of problems resulting from mold vary, and in the case
of the Ewings in Loris, the toll it has been more than financial.
It's more like a broadside against their entire lives.
"We've been married 35 years, and this is the hardest thing we've
been through," Caroline Ewing said.
"I guess we're in good company if the governor has it, too,"
Alton Ewing said.
Knight Ridder contributed to this report.Contact COLIN
BURCH at cburch@thesunnews.com or
626-0305.
WHAT MOLD CAN DO |
Sometimes it's caused by a faulty air conditioner spewing damp air
(center), other times it's simply our sticky weather taking root
from baseboard to ceiling. #HTMLInfoBox~~HOW CAN I KEEP MOLD
FROM
Keep your air conditioning at 78 degrees Fahrenheit or below. If
you have to keep the AC higher, run a dehumidifier. Check drainage
pipes, drip pans and plumbing for leaks, and clean up the water
immediately. |