COLUMBIA--Lawmakers made millions of dollars last
year by representing clients in front of boards and commissions that the
Legislature appoints. The lawyer legislators also earned fees by
representing clients in court before judges they helped elect.
There is nothing unethical or illegal about the way the lawmakers earn
their living, but one watchdog says it doesn't look good.
According to financial disclosure forms filed with the State Ethics
Commission, seven senators and their law partners collected more than $1.3
million in fees in 2004 from clients with cases before state boards and
agencies.
During the same period, 13 House members and their partners charged
clients more than $1.1 million for similar services.
"There's no doubt that a member of the Legislature has some special
status and prestige that helps him," said John Crangle, state director of
the Washington, D.C.-based group Common Cause.
For example, Sen. John Land, D-Manning, collected more than $830,000 in
fees last year from workers' compensation cases. Land has served in the
General Assembly since 1975.
"In a way, it's good advertising for me," Land said. "If you look at my
forms, you'll see I do pretty well with workers' compensation."
Rep. Jim Harrison, R-Columbia, chairman of the House Judiciary
Committee, said most of his clients don't even know he serves in the
General Assembly.
"Except for maybe 10 percent of my clients, they've never heard of me
before," said Harrison, who earned nearly $70,000 last year representing
bars and restaurants seeking liquor licenses from the Department of
Revenue.
While most lawmakers agree the potential for abuse is there, ethics
rules created in 1991 were designed to show conflicts. In addition to
reporting when they represent clients before state boards, members have to
abstain from voting on certain items if they have represented clients
before the agencies.
"The biggest influence you could have is voting on an agency's budget,
so that potential abuse is eliminated," Harrison said.
Some say the rules go too far.
Sen. Gerald Malloy, D-Harstville, who earned more than $100,000
representing clients before the state Workers' Compensation Commission
last year, said all elected officials have a conflict of interest at some
point.
"There's conflict amok in here," he said. "There's a lot of supporters
of public education who have children in public schools. What would happen
if everyone had to recuse themselves from votes dealing with schools?"