Thurmond tried to
link King, communism Aide asked FBI to
discredit rights leader By
Lauren Markoe and John Monk Knight Ridder
WASHINGTON - U.S. Sen. Strom Thurmond and
his staff tried to get the FBI to build a case against civil rights
leader Martin Luther King Jr. in 1965 on the grounds that he was
"controlled by communists."
Thurmond's efforts are documented in a memo, part of his recently
released FBI file. The memo shows the late senator's attempt to
marry two causes dear to him - fighting communism and defeating
civil rights.
On Monday, the FBI released the first installment of Thurmond's
FBI file - nearly 600 pages of sometimes heavily edited memos,
letters and other documents. The documents detail a long, secret and
mutually beneficial relationship between Thurmond and the FBI.
Another 1,700 pages remain to be released.
Thurmond was not the only conservative politician who tried to
paint the civil rights movement's leaders as "red."
But the memo plumbs the depths of Thurmond's aversion to
desegregation. And with other pages in the now-public FBI file, it
shows how much of Thurmond's politics was dedicated to fighting the
"Red Menace."
Thurmond, an iconic figure in Southern political history and an
ardent segregationist who later publicly embraced his black
constituents, was willing to go to great lengths to vilify King in
the 1960s.
The Sept. 15, 1965, memo, written by Cartha "Deke" DeLoach, a top
deputy to then-FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover, recounts a meeting in
the senator's office that was supposed to include Thurmond, but at
which he was represented by aides.
One Thurmond aide, according to the FBI memo, said Thurmond
wanted King to be exposed as a communist. DeLoach's memo recounts
the aide "stated that it was widely understood that King was
controlled by communists in this country."
The aide, whose name the FBI has edited out of the memo, also
reportedly asked DeLoach "if there was a concerted effort on the
part of the FBI to discredit King."
DeLoach wrote he responded that "such matters were beyond our
jurisdiction." It was later revealed that the FBI indeed had tried
to discredit King by secretly wiretapping his telephone and leaking
the information to reporters and others.
At the meeting, the aide also showed DeLoach recent newspaper
clippings in which Thurmond had criticized King for "injecting
himself into foreign policy at the United Nations."
Those same clippings, DeLoach wrote, criticized Arthur Goldberg,
then the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, for meeting with
King.
S.C. NAACP Vice President Joe Darby said Tuesday that those who
opposed the civil rights movement tried to label its activists as
communists.
"That was a very dirty word to get folks stirred up," he
said.
Today, Darby said, it is hard for people to realize how
inflammatory the word "communist" was, but "it made sense to the
white South in the 1960s."
"It was not a matter of logic; it was a matter of gut
reaction."
Fear of communism
Dan Carter, a nationally known civil rights historian at the
University of South Carolina, attests to the power of the
"communist" smear upon the civil rights movement.
"As late as 1962 or 1963, a majority of Americans actually
believed that communists were involved or were instigators of the
civil rights movement," he said.
Moreover, he said, the segregationist White Citizens Councils -
in their appeals to Northerners - stressed the supposed communist
leanings of civil rights workers rather than segregation.
"The segregationists played the anti-communist card," Carter
said. "It was the one card they could deal to both Northerners and
Southerners."
The FBI never conclusively found King was a communist, Carter
said. But it tried to link him to communists by saying he associated
with them or had ties to organizations that included communists.
Nevertheless, said Thurmond biographer Jack Bass, Hoover "no
doubt was a source of Strom Thurmond's belief that Martin Luther
King Jr. was heavily influenced by communists."
The 1965 memo says DeLoach expressed to Thurmond's aide an
unwillingness to take up the senator's suggestion.
Instead, DeLoach advised the staffer that it was "the prerogative
of any of the senators" to "expose" King, but they should "do their
homework well."
Asked for advice on how to proceed against King, DeLoach said he
warned that Thurmond, as a Southerner, "would no doubt be considered
subject to bias and suspicion in any statements he might make."
The Thurmond aide, according to DeLoach, also said the senator
would like to meet with DeLoach personally on the matter. Records
released by the FBI to date do not indicate whether that meeting
ever took place.
Historian Carter wonders if DeLoach told the Thurmond aides more
than the memo indicates. It was common practice in the FBI, he said,
to write memos in such a way "that nothing could come back to bite
you."
Context of history
The memo makes clear Thurmond's dislike of King. But the
senator's admirers of today ask that his actions be considered in
the context of the times - but also in the context of Thurmond's
changing record on race.
It is a complicated picture. In his 1947 inaugural address as
governor of South Carolina, Thurmond - widely considered a
progressive - promised to improve black schools.
His tack soon changed. In 1948, he ran for president on the
segregationist States Rights Party ticket, promising to fight for
separate schools, churches and swimming pools for blacks and
whites.
But Thurmond, who set records as the longest-serving and oldest
senator in history, charted a new course in the 1970s. In 1971, he
became the first Southern senator to hire a black aide.
In 1983, Thurmond voted to make Martin Luther King Day a national
holiday.
He died, at 100, in June 2003.
State Sen. John Courson, R-Richland, a longtime Thurmond friend
and supporter, said Thurmond's criticism of King must be understood
in context.
The senator and many other Americans were genuinely concerned
about the spread of communism, Courson said.
The spy trial of State Department official Alger Hiss, the
selling of secret hydrogen bomb plans to the Soviet Union, and the
hearings of U.S. Sen. Joseph McCarthy into communism in the State
Department provoked widespread fear.
"One didn't know whether one's next-door neighbor was a Marxist
or not," Courson said.
In hindsight, he said, it is not legitimate to link the civil
rights movement with communism, said Courson, who wants Thurmond
remembered for - among other things - his efforts to reach out to
blacks in the decades after the civil rights movement.
Communism and civil rights
The tactic of smearing advocates of racial equality with the
communist label has its roots in the pre-Civil War South, said
College of Charleston history professor Bernard Powers.
In those days of slavery, he said, white people feared Northern
abolitionists and would say such things as, "If it were not for
these outside agitators, our blacks would be tranquil and life in
the South would go on as normal."
"Someone like Strom Thurmond is not consciously thinking about
abolition," Powers continued, "but there were unspoken assumptions
that were passed along to those who attempted to undermine the civil
rights movement."
In the 1920s and 1930s, American communists were outspoken in
saying white supremacy was wrong. In the early 1930s, communists
provided lawyers to help blacks charged with rape in the notorious
Scottsboro case in Alabama.
But mid-century, communists lost influence as the civil rights
movement gained strength. Black people became wary of associating
with
communists. |