Sustained reform
for state schools yields PACT gains
SIX YEARS AGO, South Carolina students first sat for the Palmetto
Achievement Challenge Test. The youngest of those children are in
ninth grade today. They are the first complement of our public
school students to have taken the exam in third through eighth
grades. For those young people, the introduction of this test may
seem a lifetime ago. But in the long history of our state, we remain
in the earliest days of what must be a sustained movement toward
excellence.
The release of 2004 PACT scores last week shows the wisdom in
this long-term, comprehensive, standards-based approach. Students in
grades three through eight were tested in math, science, social
studies and English/language arts. That results in 24 statewide
scores, 21 of which were up in 2004. Only the scores for
fourth-grade math and sixth-grade science and English/language arts
saw declines.
Other results saw some impressive gains. Third-graders overall
turned in the best results, with 86 percent of them meeting state
standards in English/language arts and 83 percent in math. Third
graders meeting the state social studies standards rose 11
percentage points to 72 percent.
There was progress in the important area of closing the
achievement gap. African-American third-graders bettered the
statewide improvement in social studies by 3 percentage points, and
those living in poverty exceeded the statewide improvement by 4. In
fifth-grade English/language arts, black students exceeded overall
improvement by 5 points and children on free or reduced-price lunch
did so by 4. If South Carolina is ever to live up to the promise of
equal educational opportunity for all, students in those groups must
continue to improve more rapidly than the state average.
Certainly for the individual students and schools involved, the
higher scores represent individual accomplishment. But the
implication for our state is much greater — and certainly more
meaningful than the decline reported the week before in the narrower
SAT test. The architects of this standards and accountability system
sought to craft a movement toward school excellence that would
outlive the whims of any political season. It is a testament to
these founders’ wisdom that their movement has held out until today,
and is producing results.
Those founders were, by-and-large, outsiders to the legislative
process. They were our state’s business and economic leaders. They
saw the great drain that an inadequate school system places on our
state’s economic future. These caring individuals took the time to
research, craft and launch a statewide movement for improvement.
Their successors in the leadership of South Carolina’s business and
political communities today must be equally committed to funding and
sustaining long-term educational improvement.
We must not sacrifice our students’ progress and potential to
political whims of the moment. That includes the particularly
foolish notion that draining public school dollars to pay for
tuition tax credits would somehow represent progress. What South
Carolina and its students need is a stronger, better-funded
commitment to the proven route of standards and accountability for
better schools and better outcomes. If state leaders stay the course
on this well-conceived plan, 2004’s gains on PACT scores will prove
to be but incremental steps toward a brighter future for all those
who grow up, learn and live in South Carolina. |