Pediatricians tout the health benefits of
breast-feeding, citing reams of data showing it helps babies fight
infection, wards off allergies and stimulates brain growth. The federal
government pushes it, even passing laws that protect mothers who nurse on
government property.
|
GRACE
BEAHM/STAFF |
Lori
Rueger holds her 2-month-old daughter, Alessandra, at Mount
Pleasant Towne Centre, where Rueger said she was not welcome
to breast-feed her daughter while shopping at Victoria's
Secret. | |
South Carolina has gone so far as to name breast-feeding one of the top
weapons in its war on obesity. Nonetheless, the Palmetto State isn't among
the more than 35 states that have laws guaranteeing women the right to
nurse in public.
Moms in the Charleston area say they're usually able to find a quiet,
private place to breast-feed while they're out and about with their
babies, but raised eyebrows and rude store clerks still are commonplace.
When Lori Rueger's 2-month-old daughter, Alessandra, got fussy at Towne
Centre in Mount Pleasant recently, Rueger asked a clerk at Victoria's
Secret if she could use one of the store's dressing rooms to nurse. The
clerk, Rueger said, told her she should go to the public restroom next
door at Old Navy.
To Rueger and many other breast-feeding moms, that's not acceptable.
"Would you want to eat in the same room where someone was defecating?"
Rueger said. "I wouldn't even bring a soda into a bathroom because I'm so
afraid of germs."
A spokesman from Victoria's Secret's parent company, Limited Brands,
said the clerk merely suggested that Rueger "might be more comfortable" in
the bathroom and that there's no specific company policy banning
breast-feeding in its stores.
Rueger, who bottle-fed her first child, is an unlikely advocate, given
that she's so shy about nursing that she bought pricey shirts to keep
herself covered while Alex is feeding and isn't comfortable nursing in
front of family members.
The incident has spurred the 29-year-old stay-at-home mom into action,
though. She's sent e-mails to state legislators, the American Civil
Liberties Union, a New Jersey attorney specializing in nursing mothers'
rights and to all her friends.
"I'm just really stunned and shocked," she said. "It just gives you the
shivers, that a poor infant is being denied."
It's not lost on her that the company in question makes its money
selling sexy lingerie with ads featuring scantily clad women.
Some mothers say they are frustrated that breast-feeding in public
raises eyebrows while sexual images are common in TV, advertising and the
Internet.
"The only reason it's there is to nurse your baby," said Elizabeth
Gush, a Mount Pleasant mother of two who has helped educate other new moms
about breast-feeding. "If someone confronted me, I'd say, 'This is how God
intended for me to feed my baby, so if you have a problem, you can take it
up with him.' "
Last year, a Columbia mother feeding her baby in a bank was asked to go
the bathroom or leave the premises. The issue has sparked debate
nationally, too, with moms in New York City and Washington, D.C., staging
"nurse-ins" on street corners and in coffee shops, pleading for laws that
protect breast-feeding moms.
State laws give women the right to breast-feed in any public place
she's allowed to be, from movie theaters to the county courthouse. With no
similar laws on the books in South Carolina, it's ultimately up to
individual businesses to decide how to handle the needs of nursing moms.
Law enforcement, though, is likely to come down on a mother's side if
anyone complains.
"I can't imagine a police officer taking action against someone who's
nursing a baby," said Lt. Shawn Livingston, an officer with the Mount
Pleasant Police Department, who noted that women are welcome to come to
the department's substation at Towne Centre if they need a place to feed
their babies. "It all comes down to good common sense, and a kid's got to
eat."
Because babies need to be fed on demand until they reach about 6
months, nursing moms in the Charleston area quickly suss out the best
spots to nurse while running errands. Upscale department stores, for
instance, tend to have sitting rooms attached to restrooms where moms can
breast-feed in relative privacy.
Dressing rooms are a popular choice, too, and women involved in
breast-feeding advocacy groups say store clerks generally are helpful. At
other times, especially when a public bathroom is the only alternative,
moms head to their cars at feeding time.
"If you don't feed them when they're hungry, they holler and make a lot
of noise," said Sharon Spriggs, an international board-certified lactation
consultant with the state Department of Health and Environmental Control's
Trident district. "That's much more upsetting to be around than someone
feeding a quiet baby."
Few new mothers plan how to handle public nursing, so lactation
consultants often give tips as part of their training. It's unrealistic to
expect women to shutter themselves in their homes the whole time they're
nursing, but roadblocks outside the home tend to decrease the amount of
time moms stick with it, said Jean Rhodes, manager of the Medical
University of South Carolina's lactation consultation service and center.
In South Carolina, less than 60 percent of mothers breast-feed,
compared to about 70 percent nationally, so troubles with public nursing
encroach on already tenuous territory, said Rhodes, an international
board-certified lactation consultant who holds a doctorate in nursing
science.
It all makes for a confusing set of messages, said Elizabeth Cook, a
James Island mother of three girls, a 5-year-old and 2-year-old twins, all
of whom she breast-fed.
"Every expert in the world says it's the best thing to do for your
baby," she said. "But women are made to feel like they're stripping and
just made to feel guilty."