COLUMBIA--By the time the 2003 General Assembly
adjourned Thursday afternoon, the legislative session had turned into a
chaotic circus of partisan posturing, filibustering and deal-brokering.
And that was just in the Senate anteroom.
In the end, lawmakers limped away from the Statehouse with a bare-bones
$5 billion budget, the prospect of a $500 million budget deficit come next
year's session, and no way to come back and override any veto Gov. Mark
Sanford makes in the next week.
Although Republicans declared victory for holding the line on taxes and
Democrats criticized the GOP for failing to fund the state's basic needs,
both sides left the capital sounding like a losing high school football
team muttering "just wait until next year."
In fact, much of the major work the Legislature hoped to accomplish
this year, such as Medicaid reform, Public Service Commission reform, a
referendum on minibottles and government restructuring, will have to wait
until next year.
But in the final minutes of thesession, the General Assembly managed to
lower the state's legal blood alcohol limit to .08, pass campaign finance
reform and maintain K-12 per-pupil spending at this year's level.
The day began with Democrats throwing a wrench into Republican plans to
extend the session by a few days to deal with any vetoes Sanford makes to
the 2003-04 budget.
To extend the session, which by law had to end at 5 p.m. Thursday, the
Legislature would have had to approve a sine die resolution by a
two-thirds majority, which meant both parties would have to agree.
Although the House passed the extension, Senate Democrats refused to go
along.
The trick ensures that, barring a Sanford call for a special session,
any vetoes the governor makes will stand until at least January, when the
General Assembly reconvenes. Sen. John Land, the Democratic leader, said
Republicans had mismanaged the state's finances terribly and not lived up
to responsibilities and he did not see any sense in costing taxpayers
$75,000 a day for an extended session to let them do more.
"When the people of South Carolina really find out what has been done
to education and health care, they are really going to be excited," said
Land, D-Manning. "Democrats put up plans to raise the revenue and the
Republican majorities in both houses defeated them. The blame lies at
their feet for the worst budget in South Carolina history."
The Democratic Caucus held a press conference on the Statehouse steps
giving the Legislature an "F" in every category except consumer
protection, which earned a "C" because of the predatory lending act. Rep.
James E. Smith, the House Democratic leader, said the
Republican-controlled House had rigged the budget so badly that, "they
raided a $4,000 donation box to help balance a $5 billion budget."
Rep. Jerry Govan, chairman of the House Black Legislative Caucus, said
that voters will remember this budget when election time rolls around in
2004.
Meanwhile, the Senate was backed up on its work as Sen. John Kuhn,
R-Charleston, filibustered a research and economic development bond bill
for hours, cutting into work time. After Democrats refused to agree to the
session extension, senators popped up left and right stopping bills.
Senate President Pro Tem Glenn McConnell, R-Charleston, said the logjam
would take up so much time that several important bills would not pass
this year.
"I think they (legislators) have done what my daddy always said you
shouldn't do, which is get mad enough to cost yourself money," McConnell
said.
Passage of the .08 DUI legislation came literally in the final minutes
of the session. A conference committee of House and Senate members, with
the unusual presence of the governor at the table, was still arguing on
the tougher drunken driving law with just 40 minutes left in the session.
The House version gave prosecutors too much power, McConnell contended,
and was taking away the rights of citizens by giving too much weight to
the verdict of a Breathalyzer.
One of the most outspoken proponents of the bill, Rep. JoAnne Gilham,
R-Hilton Head, tried to fight off Senate language to weaken the bill by
asking the state attorney general to file suit against the U.S. government
for mandating the law change; but McConnell refused to back down.
"The Senate's not to blame for this. You sent us a defective bill,"
McConnell said.
After the 5 p.m. adjournment, House Speaker David Wilkins fired back at
Democrats, saying that the General Assembly had devoted a higher
percentage of the state's budget to K-12 education than any other
Legislature.
"We made the most out of the limited resources we had available and
made K-12 our highest priority," Wilkins said. "Just like families in
South Carolina, when we don't have money, we have to make do with less."
The speaker said that with no rosy revenue picture on the horizon, he
expected the House to work on "major tax reform" next January.
And Sanford said that campaign finance reform, DMV restructuring and
the DUI legislation were good wins for his first legislative session,
which he said was good for building the relationships in the Legislature
he will need to pass the government restructuring and tax reform
initiatives that he stumped for in his campaign.
He dismissed Democrats' charges that he had not been an effective
leader. Rep. Doug Jennings, D-Bennettsville, said that "it's ironic that
Sanford campaigned against Gov. Hodges for a failure of leadership and
then when the going gets tough, put on his shorts and went to Bermuda."
Sanford said that being the first governor in 50 years not to have been
a part of state government before his election, there was no way he could
come in and bully people around in a state dominated by the Legislature.
"I think it's about relationships at the state level," Sanford said.
"Anybody who comes into this system and says that he knows it all is wrong
and setting himself up for failure. As a result of work this year, we'll
be better positioned for setting priorities in the next session."
Sanford, who may see little incentive for calling lawmakers back to
Columbia to override his vetoes, nevertheless said he would consider the
option of calling the General Assembly back for special session. But most
Statehouse insiders consider that an unlikely option.