Age Of Defendant Troubled Jurors In Zoloft Defense Trial
CHARLESTON, S.C.
-- Christopher Pittman's age troubled jurors who debated whether he
should be convicted as an adult of two counts of murder for killing his
grandparents with a shotgun when he was 12 years old.
In the end, after more than six hours of deliberating over two
days, the jury on Tuesday convicted Pittman, who maintained the
anti-depressant Zoloft made him manic and he couldn't tell right from
wrong.
The prosecution countered he was simply angry at his grandparents
for disciplining him for choking a younger student on a school bus.
Following the slayings, Pittman burned the couple's Chester County home
and drove off in their car.
"If Chris Pittman had been 25 we could have come to a decision
much, much earlier. Because of his age it was very, very difficult," said
Arnold Hite, the jury foreman and a Charleston Southern University
professor who said he was speaking for himself.
Pittman was sentenced to 30 years on each count. Circuit Court
Judge Danny Pieper ordered the sentences to run concurrently.
Pittman, now 15 and being tried as an adult, hung his head as the
verdict was read.
"I know it's in the hands of God. Whatever he decides on, that's
what it's going to be," Pittman told the judge. Thirty years was the
minimum sentence Pieper could give; the maximum was life.
Pittman's father, Joe, told Pieper he supports his son even though
the victims of the November 2001 shootings were Joe Pittman's parents.
"I love my son with all of my heart, as I did my mom and dad," he
said. "And mom and dad, if they were here today, would be begging for
mercy as well."
Later, Joe Pittman called on South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford and
President Bush to pardon his son. He said he is a Gulf War veteran and
urged the officials to "give my son the benefit of the doubt."
Pittman's sister, Danielle Pittman Finchum, said on NBC's "Today"
show Wednesday that her brother is not guilty and the family will keep
fighting for his release.
"I think everybody failed him in some way or another. I mean, you
can't go through life and not fail somebody in a certain way," she said.
"We're going to fight for him and if I have to keep fighting for the next
29 years to get him out, he's not going to stay in there the full time
that he's supposed to."
Peterson, the juror, said the jury was initially divided on the
drug's impact as well as on the question of Pittman's youth.
"It bothered me a lot," she said. "It was not an easy decision. But
everyone kept saying, 'Look at the evidence. Look at the evidence.' "
As for Pittman "I don't think he was a bad seed, I think he did
crazy things as a boy growing up," Peterson said. "He didn't have a stable
home life. But that doesn't excuse what he did."
"We're devastated. We're heartbroken. We're mystified the state
chooses to treat a 12-year-old as an adult," defense attorney Andy Vickery
told reporters later. "Is it consistent with our notion of decency ... to
try 12-year-olds for murder?"
Prosecutor Barney Giese said he has sympathy for the Pittmans.
"Absolutely. I have sympathy for everyone in this case. It's a
tragic case," he said. "But I also have sympathy for Joe and Joy Pittman."
Christopher Pittman was convicted of murdering 66-year-old Joe and
62-year-old Joy Pittman. He initially told police that a black man had
shot his grandparents and burned the house and kidnapped him.
Prosecutors said they didn't think the Zoloft defense was viable.
"I really think that was a smoke screen," prosecutor John Meadors
said later. "He just happened to be on an anti-depressant when this
happened."
Zoloft is the most widely prescribed anti-depressant in the United
States, with 32.7 million prescriptions written in 2003.
Pfizer, the manufacturer of Zoloft, issued a statement saying it
was a tragic case and that the testimony showed Pittman needed help before
the slayings.
"Zoloft didn't cause his problems nor did the medication drive him
to commit murder. On these two points, both Pfizer and the jury agree,"
the statement said.
Last October, the Food and Drug Administration ordered Zoloft and
other antidepressants to carry "black box" warnings -- the government's
strongest warning short of a ban -- about an increased risk of suicidal
behavior in children.
The case was one of the first in the United States in which a
juvenile claimed the effects of an anti-depressant caused him to kill,
Vickery said earlier.
"We don't intentionally hurt the ones we love. But I have an adult
brain and you try to think about what a child was thinking," Christine
Peterson, 54, of North Charleston, a juror who is the grandmother of a
12-year-old.
"I'm sure many of us had sleepless nights," she added.
Copyright 2005 by The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.