The state's eight health and human service
agencies should be merged under the authority of a single Cabinet member,
according to a Legislative Audit Council report released Tuesday.
Together, the agencies control $5.7 billion, or about 38 percent of the
state budget. Three agencies have Cabinet members the governor appoints,
but five do not.
The agencies include the departments of Alcohol and Other Drug Abuse
Services (DAODAS), Disabilities and Special Needs, Health and
Environmental Control, Health and Human Services, Mental Health, Social
Services, Vocational Rehabilitation, and the Commission for the Blind.
Consolidating the agencies would make it easier to get help from state
government, the report said. It also could reduce administrative costs.
State Rep. Rex Rice, R-Easley, has introduced a bill to implement much
of the recommendations, and he tied it to a cigarette tax increase to fund
Medicaid.
"We've got to fix health care," Rice said. "We've got to put some
limits on the growth and figure out how to streamline agencies and
coordinate agencies. It's going to take some change."
It was the audit council's second report in a week dealing with health
care. Last week, auditors recommended ways the state could save Medicaid
dollars. This week, the report focused on non-Medicaid health and human
service issues.
In addition to combining agencies, the report recommended consolidating
four areas where similar services are provided by more than one agency:
addiction treatment, rehabilitation, programs for emotionally disturbed
children, and senior and long-term care.
For instance, Health and Human Services funds various senior and
long-term care services. Social Services has a unit that investigates
senior abuse and neglect. Mental Health owns two nursing homes that
provide institutional long-term care. DHEC provides home health services.
The report recommends consolidating these services - except for home
health - under a single, freestanding agency, or under either Social
Services or Health and Human Services.
Mental Health Director George P. Gintoli, whose department has its
5,100 employees, 9,500 volunteers and 24 mental health centers and
inpatient facilities, praised the council's report, which he called
"conscientious and thoughtful."
Gintoli said he would help implement its recommendations, some of which
the department already has been working toward, such as developing
performance measures.
Roy Mathis, speaker of the Silver Haired Legislature, a senior
advo-cacy group, said centralizing senior care services could improve
security and quality of care in long-term care facilities around the
state.
Duplicating services increases costs and can make it tough to know
where to get help, the report said. Planning is fragmented, and agencies
spend extra resources on interagency referrals and service coordination.
The report had a handful of other recommendations. Two of them dealt
with agency billing at Mental Health and DHEC.
Mental Health collects an average of 10 percent of the amount billed to
clients and 15 percent of what's billed to insurance companies. By being
more aggressive, the department could collect more from people without
insurance. Every 10-percent increase in that group would bring in an
additional $840,000.
John Hutto, spokesman for the department, agreed that collections can
be increased, but the high number of uninsured patients would make it
difficult.
DHEC, meanwhile, should be more aggressive in collecting money owed
from its health service clients, the report said. Doing so could allow the
agency to provide more services.
Jan Easterling, DHEC spokeswoman, said the department has known about
the need for a centralized billing system for some time and is working on
it.
Gov. Mark Sanford said the report advances the notion of fiscal
responsibility and accountability in government.
"We don't accept waste and duplication in the business world, and we
shouldn't accept it from state government, either," he said in a
statement. "We're in a situation with the budget where we can't afford
inefficiency and a lack of accountability."