The Winyah power plant near Georgetown nearly
doubled its annual emissions of three toxic pollutants in the past nine
years, according to a report released Thursday by a coalition of
environmentalists. U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham said the report was done by a
group whose members have a political agenda.
The Clear the Air coalition cited the Santee Cooper plant as among the
worst in the country for increases in the amount of nitrogen oxide, sulfur
dioxide and carbon dioxide discharged.
Santee Cooper said the accusation is unfair.
"In 1995, Winyah was shut down the entire year except for two weeks
because of a turbine fire," said utility spokeswoman Laura Varn. If the
1995 numbers are removed, the plant's increase drops by half for carbon
dioxide and nine-tenths for nitrogen oxide. Moreover, the amount of sulfur
dioxide emitted by the plant decreases.
"It's important to extract fact from fiction," Varn said. "Santee
Cooper meets or exceeds all state and federal environmental standards."
The report was released as the Senate begins subcommittee hearings on
the Bush administration's Clear Skies Act, which contains provisions
opposed by environmental groups.
A spokeswoman for the U.S. Public Interest Research Group, one of the
coalition members, said the report relied on federal Environmental
Protection Agency numbers and didn't break down days of operation for as
many as 700 of the biggest polluters it included in the report.
"We will be looking into ways to verify this in future reports so that
these types of discrepancies don't reoccur," said PIRG spokeswoman Kate
Prevost.
"The Winyah plant still increasedits emissions of sulfur dioxide and
carbon dioxide if we take the period from 1996 to 2003," she said.
"The bottom line is that the people downwind of this power plant, the
people most at risk, are they better off? The answer is no."
In the report, South Carolina's 13 power plants ranked 18th worst among
the states in 2003 for the amount of sulfur dioxide discharged (a 15
percent increase), 21st in the amount of nitrous oxide (15 percent
decrease) and 24th in carbon dioxide (48 percent increase).
The report found that nine of the state's 13 electric power plants
increased carbon dioxide emissions from 1995 to 2003, including Winyah,
Santee Cooper's Cross and Jefferies plants in upper Berkeley County and
South Carolina Electric & Gas Co.'s Williams plant in Goose Creek.
SCE&G's Canadys plant in Colleton County decreased its emissions.
Carbon dioxide emission is the primary cause of global warming, Prevost
said. Nitrogen oxide causes smog. Nitrogen oxide and sulfur dioxide, or
soot, have been shown to cause asthma and other lung problems.
The toxins, along with the neurotoxin mercury, are the major pollutants
released by power plants, she said.
A PIRG news release said the Clear Skies initiative's proposed "cap and
trade" rules allow the dirtiest plants to delay cleanups by buying credits
from newer and cleaner plants. It characterizes South Carolina plants as
among the oldest and dirtiest in the nation.
"The Bush administration plan allows power plants to become dirtier and
dirtier," Prevost said. "We urge Senators (Jim) DeMint and (Lindsey)
Graham to do what's in the best interests of South Carolina."
"The president's plan caps the emissions of a thousand power plants
nationwide, permanently cuts three kinds of emissions and forces
reductions without lawsuits," said DeMint spokesman Wesley Denton, whose
boss sits on the subcommittee. "His belief is the Clear Skies Act clears
up the air, clears out the courts and creates jobs."
Graham's spokesman, Kevin Bishop, said PIRG has a political agenda.
"Senator Graham appreciates PIRG's interest in promoting a cleaner
environment. If PIRG has a genuine concern for promoting clean energy,
they will reverse course and support President Bush's and Senator Graham's
efforts to build new nuclear power plants in the United States."
Varn said that by 2009, 90 percent of Santee Cooper's facilities will
have state-of-the art environmental technology.
"We live here, too. I have a 17-month-old child, and I would not be
working for a company if I thought they were hurting my child," she said.
"There are a lot of different reports," said Brian Duncan, SCE&G
spokesman.
"We do and will comply with all regulations of state and federal
agencies whose responsibility it is to look out for the health and safety
of the public. We have spent hundreds of millions of dollars to meet
changing environmental regulations in the past decade, and that is
ongoing."