GOP takes aim at
Spratt yet again
By WAYNE
WASHINGTON Senior
Writer
southern politiciannus democratica. Southern Democrat. Elected
official with moderate views residing in one of the former states of
the Confederacy. Tends to be socially conservative and pro-defense.
Near extinction.
CHERAW — If there were endangered species entries for
Southern Democrats, it would read like that. And next to the entry
would be the calm visage of John Spratt.
He’d be pictured in a place like Cheraw, a Chesterfield County
town at the elbow of U.S. 52 and S.C. 9, where residents happily
cling to their motto: “Prettiest Town in Dixie.”
Spratt was there Thursday night under a plastic white tent,
accepting the gratitude for his help in keeping their local bus
system afloat financially.
Shiny black letters, just affixed to a nearby building, announced
it as the John M. Spratt Jr. Transportation Center.
Looking up at it as the evening closed, Spratt grinned
sheepishly.
“Gives you some tingles,” he said. “Feels good to help
people.”
To be among the last of a dying breed is not a mantle anyone
wants to claim, but the ranks of Southern Democrats, particularly
white Southern Democrats, get thinner with each election.
Some, like recently retired U.S. Sen. Zell Miller of Georgia,
have railed against that reality, blasting fellow Democrats for
failing to keep faith with regional values.
Others, like U.S. Sen. Richard Shelby of Alabama, have simply
changed colors, trading in their blue Democratic coat for a red
Republican one that lets them blend in seamlessly.
And then there is Spratt, who once again seeks re-election this
fall and once again faces determined, well-funded Republican
opposition.
Plagued by lobbying scandals and led by a president whose
popularity continues to lag, Republicans nationally are guarding
against the possibility of losing control of Congress this fall.
Picking up seats held by Democrats would balance out losses and
increase the likelihood of maintaining control.
So Spratt’s race takes on more urgency than usual.
‘MY BAG IS THE BUDGET’
First elected 24 years ago, Spratt is a Yale-educated lawyer and
former Oxford scholar. Balding and jowly, with an even, accented
voice, he is a man devoid of flair.
At a Rotary Club luncheon in Columbia last week, the type of
venue where a politician gets to show off his oratory skills, Spratt
instead gave a tutorial on the budget deficit, complete with
overhead projector slides and very, very large numbers.
“My bag,” he explained over reading glasses, “is the budget.”
It was the catchiest thing he said all afternoon.
At a Social Security symposium in Florence in 2004, U.S. Rep. Jim
Clyburn — a close friend and staunch supporter — playfully warned
the audience that his Democratic colleague could answer any question
they had with a level of specificity that could be numbing.
Indeed, Spratt, using the mastery of policy detail he has
acquired as the top Democrat on the House Budget Committee, went on
to dissect President Bush’s call for retirement accounts. He used
terms like solvency and actuary — words typically seen in mail no
one wants to read.
But in politics, mastery of detail is no cloak of invincibility.
Spratt faces a threat that endangers all animals, political or
otherwise: a hostile habitat.
A RED DISTRICT
Among the state’s six congressional districts, the 5th District
is among the least homogenous.
Thanks to redistricting, it has changed some over the years,
covering less of Sumter County but all of Darlington County and some
of Florence County. The district now stretches from Cherokee County
in north central South Carolina over to Dillon County in the eastern
portion of the state and includes all or parts of 12 other
counties.
There are Charlotte suburbanites, whose new shopping centers rise
from recently turned red dirt, and Pee Dee farmers, whose lives
still spring from the darker soil of their region. It is the home of
the Catawba Indians and the disputed birthplace of Andrew Jackson,
war hero, president and infamous Indian killer.
The district is 64 percent white and about 32 percent black.
Its population center, York County, is growing rapidly, with a
portion of newcomers moving south of Charlotte to escape high taxes.
Such voters tend to vote Republican.
George W. Bush comfortably carried the district against Vice
President Al Gore in 2000 and swamped U.S. Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass.,
four years later.
Every few years, Republicans send in money and a fresh candidate,
hoping to claim congressional territory they believe should be
theirs.
Larry Sabato, director of the University of Virginia’s Center for
Politics, said the race is on his “watchlist” of competitive
contests.
“That district leans Republican in many ways, but balancing that
is Spratt’s incumbency and his relatively moderate voting record,”
Sabato said.
Added Merle Black, a political science professor at Emory
University who specializes in Southern politics: “It’s a district
for John Spratt. It’s not a district for any other Democrat.”
GEARING UP
State Rep. Ralph Norman, a York County real estate developer, has
the blessing of the White House to take on Spratt. President Bush’s
top political adviser, Karl Rove, headlined a fundraiser for Norman
on Friday in Columbia.
Norman had raised $420,429 through Dec. 31 — nearly all of it
still in the bank. That’s a large figure for a challenger and one
that indicates how eager national Republican officials are to pry
the seat from Democratic hands.
“South Carolina’s 5th (District) is one of the best pickup
opportunities for Republicans in the entire country,” said Jonathan
Collegio, spokesman for the National Republican Congressional
Committee.
“President Bush carried the district by 15 points (in 2004).
Spratt’s voting record has been drifting leftward. He voted 90
percent of the time with (California U.S. Rep.) Nancy Pelosi, who is
a very liberal member.”
Spratt and his allies downplay the link to Pelosi, who is in line
to become speaker if her party wins control of the House. Pelosi has
chosen Spratt as the House Democrats’ point man on budget issues, a
link Republicans will look to exploit.
Spratt said Pelosi chose him to be part of the party’s leadership
structure because he is a moderate and because he can speak for
like-minded Democrats.
“I’m my own man,” he said.
On many key votes, particularly those involving social issues,
Spratt and Pelosi parted ways:
• Spratt voted in favor of
allowing the Boy Scouts to ban gays. Pelosi voted against that
bill.
• Spratt voted to ban so-called
partial birth abortion. Pelosi opposed a ban.
• Spratt, rebuffed in his attempt
to have the United States give weapons inspectors more time, voted
to give President Bush the authority to use force in Iraq. Pelosi
voted against that measure.
“John has been serving South Carolina for a very long time — long
before anyone in South Carolina ever heard of Nancy Pelosi,” said
Clyburn, annoyed with the comparison. “What’s that got to do with
anything?”
There have been other Democratic bogeymen, figures whose names or
images on campaign mail were supposed to illicit gasps. Archetypal
Thomas “Tip” O’Neill, the massive Massachusetts pol whose very image
said liberal Democrat. Bespectacled Jim Wright of Texas with the
big, car salesman smile, laid low by scandal.
And now there’s Nancy Pelosi, a liberal and — Republicans rarely
fail to point out — a San Franciscan.
Spratt has worked with each of the three. He said his
relationship with Pelosi helps his district and the state.
“What it means is, when we have a leadership decision to be made,
I’m at the table,” he said.
Ratings from the American Civil Liberties Union, a liberal
political action group that rates how often members of Congress vote
in favor of its positions, do not show Spratt drifting left.
In the first three years it rated Spratt — 1984, 1986 and 1988 —
the congressman received an average rating of 67.3. Spratt’s most
recent ACLU ratings — covering 2000, 2002 and 2004 — average
45.3.
At the same time, Spratt’s ratings from the American Conservative
Union, a political action group, have remained steady, though low.
He had an average rating of 24.8 from 1983 to 1987 and a rating of
24.2 from 2000 to 2004.
Norman said Spratt has low ratings from other conservative groups
as well.
“What I offer people is a pretty stark choice,” he said. “He’s
got a liberal voting record. You’ve got me, a fiscal conservative
right up and down the line.”
AIMING FOR NOVEMBER
Norman is being challenged in the Republican Party primary by
Park Gillespie, a former public school teacher who is short on money
but long on religious and conservative zeal.
Both are convinced the district should thank Spratt for his years
of service and move on.
“John is off the reservation and has been for some time,”
Gillespie said. “He is voting with California Eight (Pelosi’s
district) far more than he votes with South Carolina Five.”
Carl Gullick, former chairman of the York County Commission, has
heard the barbs being thrown at Spratt. Like Norman and Gillespie,
he, too, thought Spratt was no longer a good fit for the
district.
Gullick challenged Spratt in 2000 but lost decisively, getting 39
percent of the vote while 59 percent went to the congressman.
“What I learned is, it’s darned hard to beat an incumbent,”
Gullick said.
Norman has top-tier, national Republican support. But Gullick
said Norman not only has to beat back Gillespie in the Republican
primary in June, but he also has to continue to stay close to Spratt
as Election Day draws near. Otherwise, big Republican donors will be
increasingly hesitant to write checks.
“When we get to September, if the polls aren’t real close, they
cut off funding,” Gullick said. “It doesn’t matter what they
promised you.”
Spratt outraised Gullick nearly 3-to-1.
SOLID SUPPORT
If his stop in Cheraw on Thursday was any indication, Spratt has
a deep well of support there.
In May 2004, he had written a letter to the Federal Transit
Administration asking it to forgive nearly $900,000 in debt the Pee
Dee Regional Transportation Authority racked up because of financial
mismanagement.
The FTA, assuaged in part by new management at the authority,
forgave the debt. None of the speakers who came before the podium
mentioned the debt forgiveness, but Spratt alluded to it in his own
remarks.
“I’d be the first to admit, and I think you would be, too, that
the (authority) has had its problems,” he said. “But if you look at
its history, it’s one of taking steps forward.”
Spratt did not speak long.
Posing for pictures and introducing himself to those handling the
food, he lingered until most in the tent had left.
The parking lot was nearly empty when he climbed into his white
Ford Taurus and drove off into the dark, country night.
Reach Washington at (803) 771-8385 or wwashington@thestate.com. |