S.C. Supreme Court
to hear teen’s appeal Youth was
convicted of killing his grandparents when he was
12 By NICHOLE MONROE BELL AND
HENRY EICHEL The Charlotte
Observer
The S.C. Supreme Court has decided to hear the appeal of a
Chester County teen who was convicted in the 2001 shooting deaths of
his grandparents.
The ruling means the youth, 16-year-old Christopher Pittman, will
bypass the S.C. Court of Appeals because his case “involves an issue
of significant public interest or a legal principle of major
importance,” according to the Supreme Court.
In its order, the court did not specify what issue or legal
principle merited its review.
Pittman was 12 when he shot to death Joe and Joy Pittman of
Chester. During his trial in February 2005, Pittman’s lawyers argued
the antidepressant drug Zoloft made the boy unable to know right
from wrong and led him to kill. Prosecutors said the boy knew right
from wrong because he fled the scene and lied to police when they
found him.
Pittman’s lawyers have argued that the teen shouldn’t have been
tried as an adult, and that his resulting 30-year sentence was too
harsh. Thirty years is the minimum sentence allowed under S.C. law
for murder by someone convicted as an adult.
Professor James Flanagan of the University of South Carolina Law
School said that while the Supreme Court doesn’t often bypass the
Court of Appeals, it’s not unusual when an unsettled issue of law is
at stake. Flanagan said the rule is one that the Supreme Court uses
“to bring before itself those cases that it is ultimately going to
end up hearing
anyway.” |