Leaders of the House of Representatives rightly are relieved that the
House no longer can be accused of caring more about chickens than battered
women. But that doesn't mean there should be any less determination to
give the cruel sport of cockfighting the harsher penalties it deserves,
including a new forfeiture provision on property seized from those who
violate animal fighting laws.
As House Speaker David Wilkins notes on our Commentary page today, that
body has unanimously passed a strong criminal domestic violence bill. That
bill was given priority after comments by Charleston Rep. John Graham
Altman about women who return to their abusers sparked a firestorm of
controversy. The outrage by the bill's supporters was fueled by the fact
that the House Judiciary Committee had given approval to the cockfighting
bill on the day that it had turned thumbs down on the domestic violence
legislation.
Now the question is whether opponents of the cockfighting legislation
have marshaled enough forces to all but kill that bill. Attorney General
Henry McMaster obviously was concerned enough about the bill's outcome to
send a memo to House members Tuesday.
The attorney general has been at the forefront of the crackdown on
animal abuse and has made commendable strides on the dog-fighting front.
But as he noted in his memo, cockfighting was exempted from the felony
provision of the animal fighting law, which carries a five-year, $5,000
penalty. Instead, cockfighting is a misdemeanor, punishable by 30 days in
jail or a $100 fine. According to Mr. McMaster, many who engage in
cockfighting cite the $100 fine as "the cost of doing business." The bill
would make that cost far more expensive not only for those engaged in
cockfighting but all other blood sports.
The attorney general notes that the legislation contains the same kind
of forfeiture provisions that are included in the state's drug laws. He
wrote that the forfeiture provision is needed to combat the increase in
illegal animal fighting "and the drug trafficking which supports it. Dog
fighting is a well-funded secretive sub- culture tied to the illegal drug
trade with huge six-figure jackpots at stake. Cockfighting often has huge
jackpots too. Fighting these criminals take resources."
The attorney general called on the House to "stand with law
enforcement" in support of the legislation. We would broaden that
constituency to include the majority of South Carolinians who we believe
are behind the attorney general in his campaign to rid the state of those
who profit from animal abuse.